Who has the better legacy: Donovan McNabb or Mike Vick?

[NYSTATEOFMIND]

man fukk outta here. Watching Michael Vick in 2010 after Kevin Kolb went down...that was the greatest season of any QB i've ever witnessed. Call me a stan or whatever i give zero fukks. There wasnt another more entertaining, electrifying season as that one in my 22 year life.

and how did 2011-2014 season work out?

 

[NYSTATEOFMIND]

Vick winning the Super Bowl this year though

I cant believe 9 votes for Vick...2 of them votes are probably Marcus and Michael but who are the 7 down syndrome dumb asses who voted Vick

 

[Boolean]

Vick slander is a prime characteristic of a bytch/fukk nikka

 

[NYSTATEOFMIND]

Donny easy. Made me a football fan and an eagles fan.

Wasnt perfect but was the best QB Philly has ever seen. Too bad he was never fully appreciated. Especially when Kolb came and certain fans

were ready to crown him.

You mean those kind of fan? Kolb wasnt shyt either...Kolb and Vick both wasnt shyt...Don put up better numbers and had more success than Jaworksi, my main man Cunningham and any fukkboi ( inlcuding Michael Vick) the eagles have trotted out as QB thus far

anyone who thinks Vick is better is some shiftless GED having minimum wage nigruh without a future..fukkoutta here with that Vick is better than Mcnabb bullshyt

 

[b. woods]

Ryan Clark was about to knock the shyt out of Pinkston.

 

[wire28]

Alligator body

nikka just lost it in the lights

 

[godkiller]

Vick slander is a prime characteristic of a bytch/fukk nikka

 

[Malik]

McNabb was the better quarterback. Vick the more exciting player. It's sad because time won't be that kind to #5 but, people won't forget Vick (especially PETA ). As a real deal Eagles fan, that 2010 season was special. I've never been so invested in a season before. I wanna say the 2004 T.O./McNabb season was better and it should be because they actually got to the Super Bowl but I just can't That Redskins game, Vick was God-mode out there. Morgan Freeman gave him his powers for the night. That Giants comeback game was ridiculous. That was our year man....it really was....but of course, Vick decided to risk the entire season on Riley Cooper. That racist piece of shiit.

 

[MegaTronBomb!]

McNabb's legacy is that of a perennial choker/puker, who is out of the NFL, because he refused to not be a fat fukk... regardless of his numbers, he will be remembered as the dude who could never get it done

Vick's legacy is that of a dude who got caught up in a lifestyle, didn't care about being the best QB...as long as he was the hottest QB....and ended up in prison behind it.... came back,worked at his craft, got a shot and redeemed himself.


On top of that, Vick changed the way QB's played the game....and i never saw any kid rock the number 5 because of McNabb.

 

[NYSTATEOFMIND]

Vick's legacy is that of a dude who got caught up in a lifestyle, didn't care about being the best QB...as long as he was the hottest QB....and ended up in prison behind it.... came back,worked at his craft, got a shot and redeemed himself..

How exactly did he redeem himself?
2010 was a magical season..yes..but it wasnt even a full 16 games and after that season he was medicore at best
and what lifestyle led to him not being a respectable QB ( dont give me he can run, running isnt a primary skill to play the QB position) Partying and smoking isn't something is an exclusive hobby to Michael Vick, most NFL players do the same

Vick was the more exciting QB but people overstate his importance to football

 

[mozichrome]

i swear on this site
penny (even tho his talk been quiet)
vince young
mike vick
t mac(his talk been quiet)

those athletes have this air or myth about their actual abilities that cause overrated thoughts

 

[cook]

mcnabb was a better overall QB but vick was more exciting to watch

 

[MegaTronBomb!]

How exactly did he redeem himself?
2010 was a magical season..yes..but it wasnt even a full 16 games and after that season he was medicore at best
and what lifestyle led to him not being a respectable QB ( dont give me he can run, running isnt a primary skill to play the QB position) Partying and smoking isn't something is an exclusive hobby to Michael Vick, most NFL players do the same

Vick was the more exciting QB but people overstate his importance to football

How didn't he? going from disgraced former NFL QB to a 100 Million Dollar contract...isn't redeeming yourself?

and yes, his lifestyle down in Atlanta... is what caused his downfall. most NFL players don't get federal time for trying to live like a rapper.

who said anything about him not being a respectable QB? Why is it that you new york nikkas can't read?

and no, people don't overstate his importance to football, they may overstate how great of an NFL QB he was... but act like these Dual Threat QB's in the NFL now, aren't descendents of Vick.

 

[NYSTATEOFMIND]

How didn't he? going from disgraced former NFL QB to a 100 Million Dollar contract...isn't redeeming yourself?

and yes, his lifestyle down in Atlanta... is what caused his downfall. most NFL players don't get federal time for trying to live like a rapper.

who said anything about him not being a respectable QB? Why is it that you new york nikkas can't read?

and no, people don't overstate his importance to football, they may overstate how great of an NFL QB he was... but act like these Dual Threat QB's in the NFL now, aren't descendents of Vick.

Sorry for misquoting your nonsense..you said he didnt care about being the best QB..I guess being respectable is less attainable than being the best...my bad

Do you even know why he actually got federal time?
When you say dumb shyt like dual threat QB are the descendants of Vick YOU ARE OVERSTATING HIS IMPORTANCE DUMB ASS.. not to mention that shyt is wrong..Vick and all these black dual threat QBs are the Children of Randall Cunningham...

 

[L&HH]

Outside of TO, who was Prime McNabb's best WR? Kevin Curtis, Freddie Mitchell, or James Thrash

Todd Stinkson