Who has the better legacy: Donovan McNabb or Mike Vick?

[OPTiMO]

vick is a legend, he still is probably in the top 10 most recognized names in the l.
his legacy will last longer than mcnabbs

 

[mastermind]

vick is a legend, he still is probably in the top 10 most recognized names in the l.
his legacy will last longer than mcnabbs

because you don't actually watch the NFL but play Madden only

Its McNabb and its not even close.

 

[OPTiMO]

@mastermind just because i dont jave thousands of posts and years of my life waisted posting n the coliseum doesnt mean i dont watch footbll.

if you ask casual fan, youll have to go outside (scary i know), they will know vick before mcnabb. is that not wjat a legacy is

 

[FTBS]

because you don't actually watch the NFL but play Madden only

Its McNabb and its not even close.

Exactly. How this even a discussion?

 

[FTBS]

@mastermind just because i dont jave thousands of posts and years of my life waisted posting n the coliseum doesnt mean i dont watch footbll.

if you ask casual fan, youll have to go outside (scary i know), they will know vick before mcnabb. is that not wjat a legacy is

Breh more people will know Tebow before every QB not named Manning, Brady, and Romo does that mean his legacy is greater than 90% of the QBs in the league. If you aren't taking what actually took place on the field into account then you are just having popularity/infamy contest.

 

[mastermind]

@mastermind just because i dont jave thousands of posts and years of my life waisted posting n the coliseum doesnt mean i dont watch footbll.

if you ask casual fan, youll have to go outside (scary i know), they will know vick before mcnabb. is that not wjat a legacy is

says the breh who also has thousands of posts and wasted years of his life posting on these forums


Tonya Harding has a greater legacy than Kristi Yamaguchi by your dumbass logic.

The answer is McNabb. While Vick was athletically superior to McNabb, you could argue he helped start this dual-threat QB movement also.

 

[mastermind]

white's will say mcnabb

black's will say vick


im black so u know who im rolling with

your dumbass believes this

 

[OPTiMO]

vick will be one of those names to where it doesnt really matterd what he accomplished, joe namath, he will be remembered better than he is. mcnabb wont

 

[Methodical]

I voted McNabb but I think the whole thing Vick with his dogs illegal shyt is ruined his legacy. He would have stayed ATL, could possible be won the ring and nobody gonna at him.

 

[mastermind]

Breh more people will know Tebow before every QB not named Manning, Brady, and Romo does that mean his legacy is greater than 90% of the QBs in the league. If you aren't taking what actually took place on the field into account then you are just having popularity/infamy contest.

its these new fans who only know names and "swag" and know nothing about the sport.

like this fella:

vick will be one of those names to where it doesnt really matterd what he accomplished, joe namath, he will be remembered better than he is. mcnabb wont

 

[Ineedmoney504]

I voted McNabb but Vick will always be remembered more, he is the ai of football

 

[DosCadenaz]

as a Cowboys fan and football fan in general, McNabb.

 

[OPTiMO]

its these new fans who only know names and "swag" and know nothing about the sport.

like this fella:

youre old bro, i get it.

 

[Spaceman Piff]

I voted McNabb but Vick will always be remembered more, he is the ai of football

vick is closer to penny than iverson

 

[Ineedmoney504]

vick is closer to penny than iverson

i said ive mostly cause both of them had the rough edge to them and got in trouble for it, penny was a cool nikka