Who was Better? Air Mcnair or Randall Cunningham

Who Better


  • Total voters
    59

Dr. Narcisse

Veteran
Joined
May 1, 2014
Messages
53,133
Reputation
12,291
Daps
174,649
Randall was better.

McNair had more potential. However, injuries and Jeff Fisher is why he never was a great as he could have been (still great).

Randall was allowed to play care free. McNair was restricted.
 

AlbertPullhoez

The Takeover
Bushed
Joined
Sep 7, 2012
Messages
34,224
Reputation
8,379
Daps
145,769
Reppin
Deuce Dime, TX
Y'all really gone give credit to Randall for leading a team with Chris Carter And the greatest receiver at his peak of all time Randy Moss and Robert Smith and Leroy Hoard were brad Johnson started games and they had Dennis Smith who was a revolutionary at that time.
People forget Randall was out the league for a minute before that 98 season and was Brad Johnson backup. He benefited from the GOAT rookie receiver season ever

Dude got benched the very next season for Jeff George. Randall is that dude but as a Vikings fan I'd choose Culpepper over Cunningham.
 

Bigblackted4

Superstar
Joined
Nov 19, 2016
Messages
25,859
Reputation
2,139
Daps
44,123
Reppin
Eastcleveland
People forget Randall was out the league for a minute before that 98 season and was Brad Johnson backup. He benefited from the GOAT rookie receiver season ever

Dude got benched the very next season for Jeff George. Randall is that dude but as a Vikings fan I'd choose Culpepper over Cunningham.

Culpepper had some great seasons for you guys and the teams weren't amazing at all.
 

feelosofer

#ninergang
Joined
May 17, 2012
Messages
54,157
Reputation
9,767
Daps
161,746
Reppin
Brick City, NJ
Actually, as much as I like Cunningham, prime Steve McNair was a better QB and in actuality he was underrated throughout his career, imo. Randall was the better overall athlete though.
 
Top