Who was Better? Air Mcnair or Randall Cunningham
- Thread starter Freddie.Cane
- Start date
Jparker
Innocence lost in the EAST
McNairbut who u got breh
Air McNair easily... Plus he was the first black QB to win AP NFL MVP. And did it by having the highest passer rating. Mcnair dispelled the black qb stereotype with that. Randall couldn't read defenses 
Cunningham got good stats in 98 because all he had to do was throw it up to Moss. Mcnair never had that kinda luxury
Cunningham got good stats in 98 because all he had to do was throw it up to Moss. Mcnair never had that kinda luxury
Last edited:
Self_Born7
SUN OF MAN
Cunningham.. no question
Mantis Toboggan M.D.
I’m here for the scraps
McNair took a titans team coached by Jeff fisher to the super bowl and won an MVP award. If his body could've just waited an extra 4 weeks to break down, he'd have won a super bowl too 
Conscious Pilot
Do Better.
Why can't Russ be in the conversation?
Bboystyle
FIRE MATT LAFLEUR
because he's not on their level yet. U cant live off your D and be crowned the GOAT
Conscious Pilot
Do Better.
Wilson is the first QB in NFL history with a passer rating of over 95.0 in each of his first three seasons.
Wilson has 24 games with a passer rating of 100+ in his first three seasons...more than any other QB in NFL history. Flacco, Marino, and Palmer are tied for second with 19.
He is one of only five players with at least 20 touchdown passes in each of first three seasons
Wilson holds the record for most passing yards in a playoff game by a rookie QB with 385 yards. The old record was set in 1937 by Sammy Baugh with 335 yards...that record stood for 75 years.
Hasnt missed a start yet with WOAT O Line etc etc...Obviously he has an all time great defense and they were the driving force behind the Bowl but to say he isn't well on his way to the Convo is silly.
Omar Little
It’s all in the Game Yo
Randall.
Moon>>>>>> Randall>> Mcnair= Mcnabb>>>Doug Will
Moon>>>>>> Randall>> Mcnair= Mcnabb>>>Doug Will
Cause talent matters. Lil Russ Wilson is nice but he ain't on the same level talent-wise as Cunningham and McNair. In terms of arm talent and athleticism he's not on the same level as them.
Bboystyle
FIRE MATT LAFLEUR
Wilson also throws multiple INT's against good defenses including one that cost them a SB ring. Sorry, but Wilson isnt on randall or mcnair's level as a QB. Those two can carry a team. fukk stats. Stats dont tell the whole story and if so, his stats arent impressive at all for a qb playing in today's league. He can get there but he has to play better.
when he had Lynch he was at his best. Now that he doesnt have an RB and defenses played the pass last year, he threw for 21 td's and 11int's. Thats trash right there.
Last edited:
Conscious Pilot
Do Better.
The 2nd half of 2015 when Cam Won MVP Wilson went the fukk off. Marshawn was dinged up all year as well.
I agree that last year I had higher hopes for him. But seeing him hike the ball under center and not even a split second 3 bucs defender are in front of his face which was a common theme last year, coupled with having a less than stellar Wr Corp, he still put up decent numbers and made another playoff appearance with an aging LOB. This year is a make or break if he can become top 5 QB in the league ,imo.
Bboystyle
FIRE MATT LAFLEUR
he had a top 10 D again. aging or not, his defense is more then capable of winning them games. his decent numbers aren't so decent in today's game IMO. As a packer fan, i have no pitty for any QB who doesnt have an o-line and has to throw the ball within 3 seconds as thats how Rodgers career was created. Like i said, he has the talent and time to prove he's elite.
Goat poster
KANG LIFE
Wilson's 2015 season was AMAZING.
Had cam not had a amazing year himself Russ would have won MVP.
As far as Randall/McNair I gotta go with McNair.
Maybe I'm biased cause McNair was also the best College QB I've seen.
Had cam not had a amazing year himself Russ would have won MVP.
As far as Randall/McNair I gotta go with McNair.
Maybe I'm biased cause McNair was also the best College QB I've seen.