Who was Better? Air Mcnair or Randall Cunningham

Who Better


  • Total voters
    59
Joined
May 16, 2012
Messages
39,600
Reputation
-17,881
Daps
84,297
Reppin
NULL
I'm a huge Randall fan, but if I'm being honest, McNair was a better qb, IMO.

I grew up on Steve McNair being a kid in Nashville, TN but he ain't better than Randall Cunningham. Randall Cunningham was more talented but just never had talent around him until he was in Minnesota. And even then at an old age he put up historic numbers and led the Vikings to a 15-1 record.

Randall Cunningham is the GOAT QB.
 

El Coupeacabra

Diamond Teeth Samurai
Joined
Nov 22, 2016
Messages
3,673
Reputation
1,525
Daps
21,362
Reppin
214/254/512/210/281
Cunningham underachieved tremendously. He was incredibly talented and honestly had one of the best arms in NFL History.
Blame his no offensive scheme having ass coach.

Buddy Ryan was convinced Randall was a running back who could occasionally pass and used him as such.
 

bxrfan

Superstar
Joined
Apr 2, 2015
Messages
2,989
Reputation
1,180
Daps
15,166
Reppin
Memphis Grizzlies/Auburn Tigers
This is kinda off topic but I've always hated how black QBs got so close to winning it all only to fall just short of Super Bowl glory

Gary Anderson misses a field goal in the NFC championship after going perfect all season in 98 to deny Randall's storybook ending

Kevin Dyson is tackled one yard short of the endzone in Super Bowl 34 after McNair makes an incredible play to get them within scoring range

McNabb finally gets some WR help in the form of TO and they go to the Super Bowl only to lose to New England. Now McNabb could've played better but they still had a chance to win if not for some horrible clock management down the stretch. Also the 08 NFC championship where he and the Eagles rallied from a 24-6 deficit to take the lead only to lose to a Cardinal team they had blown out on Thanksgiving

Vick's incredible comeback year in 2010 ended with an interception to Tramon Williams in the Wild Card round. It was a bad throw but Riley KKKooper could've done a better job to prevent the cb from catching that ball

In only his 10th start Kaepernick rallies the 49ers from a 28-6 deficit in Super Bowl 47 to bring them within 5 yards of winning the game, but bad playcalling in the redzone did them in. Can you imagine how different this Kaepernick situation would be looked at if he won that Super Bowl?

Russell Wilson has a chance to cement himself as the most accomplished black QB ever with a second Super Bowl win but is picked off in the endzone on a play where giving Marshawn Lynch the ball was almost a sure touchdown

Cam Newton had the NFL in the palm of his hand in 2015, winning the MVP and looking unstoppable in leading the Panthers to a 15-1 record. Then he and the Panthers play poorly in Super Bowl 50 and he hasn't been the same since

It sucks and allows white folks to run with the stupid narrative that black QBs just can't get it done when it matters most
 
Last edited:

Bboystyle

FIRE MATT LAFLEUR
Joined
May 2, 2012
Messages
49,364
Reputation
6,599
Daps
83,059
Reppin
So. Cal
This is kinda off topic but I've always hated how black QBs got so close to winning it all only to fall just short of Super Bowl glory

Gary Anderson misses a field goal in the NFC championship after going perfect all season in 98 to deny Randall's storybook ending

Kevin Dyson is tackled one yard short of the endzone in Super Bowl 34 after McNair makes an incredible play to get them within scoring range

McNabb finally gets some WR help in the form of TO and they go to the Super Bowl only to lose to New England. Now McNabb could've played better but they still had a chance to win if not for some horrible clock management down the stretch. Also the 08 NFC championship where he and the Eagles rallied from a 24-6 deficit to take the lead only to lose to a Cardinal team they had blown out on Thanksgiving

Vick's incredible comeback year in 2010 ended with an interception to Tramon Williams in the Wild Card round. It was a bad throw but Riley KKKooper could've done a better job to prevent the cb from catching that ball

In only his 10th start Kaepernick rallies the 49ers from a 28-6 deficit in Super Bowl 47 to bring them within 5 yards of winning the game, but bad playcalling in the redzone did them in. Can you imagine how different this Kaepernick situation would be looked at if he won that Super Bowl?

Russell Wilson has a chance to cement himself as the greatest black QB ever with a second Super Bowl win but is picked off in the endzone on a play where giving Marshawn Lynch the ball was almost a sure touchdown

Cam Newton had the NFL in the palm of his hand in 2015, winning the MVP and looking unstoppable in leading the Panthers to a 15-1 record. Then he and the Panthers play poorly in Super Bowl 50 and he hasn't been the same since

It sucks and allows white folks to run with the stupid narrative that black QBs just can't get it done when it matters most

Wilson will never be the best black qb regardless if he won or not breh, stop it. Most accomplished yes, but the best, hell no,far from it.
 
Top