Who was the better PF CWebb or Amare

[Shadow King]

Yet Amare made more all stars and all nba

Amare has seasons officially listed at C which in the 2000s was easier. Webb dealt with the golden age of PF.

 

[FlyRy]

Amare has seasons officially listed at C which in the 2000s was easier. Webb dealt with the golden age of PF.

i'd argue its the other way around. they both have some listed at C. Webb started his career during the golden age of the center and amare during the golden age of the PF

 

[mastermind]

At their peaks, I’m taking Amar’e

 

[AVXL]

Cwebb was the better overall player for longer but peak Amare is a better more explosive player

 

[livindajetlife]

Damn that’s a good one that’s tough .. I wanna go cwebb but Amare was nasty as well… good question

 

[Hey_zeus]

C Web would be an offensive hub today. This isn't even close

 

[Reggie]

Webber was more skilled as a passer and never got the chance to play with someone like Steve Nash who would have gotten him easy buckets like he did Amare. I'll go with Chris for this one.

 

[Yagirlcheatinonus]

Webber was more skilled as a passer and never got the chance to play with someone like Steve Nash who would have gotten him easy buckets like he did Amare. I'll go with Chris for this one.

He played with J Will and Bibby.

 

[Shadow King]

i'd argue its the other way around. they both have some listed at C. Webb started his career during the golden age of the center and amare during the golden age of the PF

It's not the other way around. Webber has 2 of 15 seasons listed at C, one of them his rookie year and the other his last year in Washington. Webb is a straight up PF by consensus and his peak coincides with just about every other PF we'd name being not only in their prime but in the Western Conference.

Meanwhile, Amare and the Suns pioneered the small ball PF/C (4 straight seasons at C and 7 overall). Most of the accolades you brought up have Amare at C, including the first Knick season where he was getting real MVP talk till Carmelo showed up. The mid-late 00s was minute staggered Duncan and ceremonial All-Star Yao in the West at C. His Knick season his only rival was Dwight.

 

[Doctor Doom]

At their peaks, I’m taking Amar’e

Cwebb was the better overall player for longer but peak Amare is a better more explosive player

I honestly believe the Suns years stunted Amare's growth as a player somewhat.

 

[Silkk]

Amare was Box Office

 

[dreskii]

cwebb and it's not close.

 

[Belize King]

Better comparison is C Webb vs Chris Bosh. Put a poll up. Both had short runs 4-6 years of all NBA basketball.

 

[42 Monks]

Better comparison is C Webb vs Chris Bosh. Put a poll up. Both had short runs 3-5 years.

Webber was better than Bosh too lol

 

[Belize King]

Webber was better than Bosh too lol

I feel the same way, but my point is it's a better comparison.