Another one:
Ric Blade - This entry is a bit different from my others. I contemplated if I should even add him as he isn't talked about much these days, unless it's in jest. He only had a two-year run as a fan favorite. Although he wasn't able to maintain a fanbase like his peers such as Ki, Joe, and Punk (which all three kept to this day), the fact remains that he played a huge role to the indie boom and was top five in terms of overness.
He was on Low-Ki's level of popularity and the biggest draw to a growing CZW as one of the original four CZW Wrestling Academy (

) graduates. He was their franchise player and busted out moves never seen in the States before. The fans ate up his... yardtard ninja?... style and couldn't wait for his next death-defying stunt. He was an indie GOD. There was only one problem:
He was absolutely HORRIBLE in-ring.
He eventually broke his ankle in 2001 and blamed then-CZW owner Zandig for not helping with medical bills, blasting him online. Fans donations poured in, but he spent the money on a Game Boy Advance for his son (seriously). He didn't return to the 'dub until the following year, but the damage was done and fans had already turned on him.
In some ways, he's actually an unsung hero as a pioneer of helping indie wrestling blow up. But he will always be seen as a joke with his matches that could fill up upcoming Botchamania's #300-312.