Who will win another SB 1st? Peyton Manning or Tom Brady?

[FTBS]

They dominate in the regular season. In the playoffs?

Tom Brady in the playoffs aside from the Denver game has been

He's become exactly what people used to criticize Peyton for being.

I don't think either one wins another one. You got ARod, Eli, Brees, Ben all in their respective primes right now and wearing the most recent 5 SB rings. Then you got young guns coming (Stafford, Cam, Freeman, Ryan, RGIII, Luck). Ravens D is still the Ravens D. Texans looking good. 9ers looking good. I honestly think their time has passed.

 

[Trip]

He's become exactly what people used to criticize Peyton for being.

I don't think either one wins another one. You got ARod, Eli, Brees, Ben all in their respective primes right now and wearing the most recent 5 SB rings. Then you got young guns coming (Stafford, Cam, Freeman, Ryan, RGIII, Luck). Ravens D is still the Ravens D. Texans looking good. 9ers looking good. I honestly think their time has passed.

People have been saying that about the Pats for like 5 years now....and then they go out and win 12+ games.

Until Brady retires that team will always be a contender.

 

[FTBS]

People have been saying that about the Pats for like 5 years now....and then they go out and win 12+ games.

Until Brady retires that team will always be a contender.

My bad I thought the thread was about winning SBs not winning 12 games and contending.

 

[Trip]

My bad I thought the thread was about winning SBs not winning 12 games and contending.

you cant be that dense.

Brady completes the pass to Welker and they're champs. The get a bye ever year, the league still cant stop their offense....you get a seat at the table you have a chance of winning the SB. There's a reason they're the favorites to win it again.

 

[FTBS]

you cant be that dense.

Brady completes the pass to Welker and they're champs. The get a bye very year....you get a seat at the table you have a good chance of winning the SB. There's a reason they're the favorites to win it again.

Contending and almost winning a SB doesn't=winning a SB just ask the Eagles from last decade or the Bills from the decade before or the Ravens who were Flacco completion away from beating the Pats last year. I didn't say they wouldn't have opportunites or come close ever again I said I thought their championship window had passed which is a totally different level and conversation.

 

[Megatron Island]

Peyton Manning has to worry about getting into the play-offs with both the Chargers and Chiefs in his division. That could be 3-4 losses per season right there.

 

[Trip]

Contending and almost winning a SB doesn't=winning a SB just ask the Eagles from last decade or the Bills from the decade before or the Ravens who were Flacco completion away from beating the Pats. I didn't say they wouldn't have opportunites or come close I said I thought their championship window had passed.

you have an elite QB like Brady you have a chance to win it every season.

Saying their window has passed makes no sense. They are the clear favorite in the AFC.

 

[LastEmperor2k2]

I honestly think their time has passed.

Yep, too many better teams out there right now.

Brady went hollywood and will never get it back.

 

[Listen]

I just want to applaud the thread start, this is a great question.

 

[Megatron Island]

And Peyton already sounding shook:

NFL Peyton Manning's plea to James Harrison - ESPN

 

[No1]

I hope you all realize that this year's Pats team is the best one of paper since 2007. Just keep that in mind as you all pop off.

 

[FTBS]

you have an elite QB like Brady you have a chance to win it every season.

Saying their window has passed makes no sense. They are the clear favorite in the AFC.

Did you not read my first post? Other teams have elite QBs. Other teams have top notch defenses. Just because a team is favored doesn't mean they are gonna win. When is the last time they weren't favored? It's just seems to me that the magic that they had when they won the 3 SBs is gone and now instead of finding ways to win they always find a way to lose.

 

[Trip]

Did you not read my first post? Other teams have elite QBs. Other teams have top notch defenses. Just because a team is favored doesn't mean they are gonna win. When is the last time they weren't favored? It's just seems to me that the magic that they had when they won the 3 SBs is gone and now instead of finding ways to win they always find a way to lose.

which teams have an elite QB and top notch defenses?

GB's defense was horrendous last year and they were the best team in football.

 

[FTBS]

I hope you all realize that this year's Pats team is the best one of paper since 2007. Just keep that in mind as you all pop off.

Didn't they lose in 2007 though?

 

[FTBS]

which teams have an elite QB and top notch defenses?

GB's defense was horrendous last year and they were the best team in football.

He's become exactly what people used to criticize Peyton for being.

I don't think either one wins another one. You got ARod, Eli, Brees, Ben all in their respective primes right now and wearing the most recent 5 SB rings. Then you got young guns coming (Stafford, Cam, Freeman, Ryan, RGIII, Luck). Ravens D is still the Ravens D. Texans looking good. 9ers looking good. I honestly think their time has passed.