who's better brady or Peyton

[Absolut]

you could put ryan tannehill in denver and they are in the hunt. the team is loaded

 

[bl2k8]

samuel picks it, and welker catches it, brady has 5 titles. manning can put all the "regular season calling his own number from the inside the 3 for 15 years" window dressing on it he wants. hes had all the firepower you can want, and the nfl changing the way its played multiple times for him and he has one ring to show for it

Pretty much. Brady gave the New England defense a lead to work with in the 2 Super Bowls he lost.

 

[Truth Hurts]

brady isnt on peytons level. brady will never have more playoff losses than peyton, or more one and done playoff seasons.

 

[Truth Hurts]

Can you imagine what brady would do with murderer and reggie wayne, and edgerrin james running??

Can you imagine the elite numbers peyton would put up with troy brown and deion branch??

 

[BLAZO da GAWD]

Brady is overrated, people really just conveniently overlook that he owes his career to Mo Lewis and Spygate.... and that they effectively replaced him with a dude who wasn't fit to start for two other NFL franchises like it was nothing.

Brady is not elite in any aspect of quarterbacking.

 

[ItzDaKiing]

I'm sayin dude straight blacked out and started making no sense at all.

 

[feelosofer]

I think Peyton Manning is better than Tom Brady but let's not act like Tom Brady hasn't been throwing to trash for the majority of his career. I mean even right now, he's playing in an offense with a banged up Gronk and Brandon Lafell as probably his best receiver, just think about that. In fact I'm not sure the Pats receivers would make the Denvers practice squad.

 

[Ineedmoney504]

Let's face Brady is a bum, Peyton would do much better wit that team Brady

Peyton would have put pressure on Tomkins and that other young wr and force them to be really good, and eat well wit Cronk all year

Let act like decker and DT was household names, now they just great, jt was bout to get cut cause he was a project who couldn't run routes, now all of a sudden peyton walked into this great team

 

[FTBS]

The silliness on both sides . Of course Brady is on Peyton's level. Based on what I have see over the last 15 years, the only thing separating these two is circumstance. It's funny how people can only recognize this in certain instances. Yes Brady would be putting up numbers with those weapons. Just like Peyton would have more rings if he had the great all around teams that weren't overly dependent on him early on in his career.

 

[Formerly known as...]

Imagine Brady with the receivers Manning has now!



Let's not act like Brady didn't create Welkers whole career.

 

[Ineedmoney504]

Imagine Brady with the receivers Manning has now!



Let's not act like Brady didn't create Welkers whole career.

nikkaz still talking bout welker like he ain't washed, fukk outta here slime

Peyton keeping this dude alive and getting him a free check, dudes doesn't do shyt, he really holding our rookie back, and he ain't getting no pt behind him

 

[malbaker86]

Another Brady vs Manning thread. How original

 

[protestor]

Can you imagine what brady would do with murderer and reggie wayne, and edgerrin james running??

Can you imagine the elite numbers peyton would put up with troy brown and deion branch??

How many super bowls did he win with moss, welker and gronk?

 

[Ineedmoney504]

How many super bowls did he win with moss, welker and gronk?

let's not go there bruh, let's no forget he had a stallworth and chad Johnson and couldn't get any of them to produce anything peyton would put up goat numbers numbers wit prime moss, welker, stallworth, ben watson, gaffeney, troy brown and a great defense

 

[DetroitEWarren]

How many super bowls did he win with moss, welker and gronk?

Yeah, going undefeated and breaking passing and receiving records meant absolutely nothing cause of a loss that came from a lucky catch. You nikkas man