Who's trophy case is more impressive?

[Ed MOTHEREFFING G]

guys like Eric Crouch, Jason White, Rahshaan Salaam and Gino Toretta have won the Heisman....the average fan has never heard of these guys. And the Heisman doesnt have nearly the prestige as it once did.

okay, and how many back up QBs and kickers have championship rings?

 

[KevCo]

Id rather have Bradys career/trophy case/life

 

[Trip]

okay, and how many back up QBs and kickers have championship rings?

that's a silly comparison. Tom Brady's career isnt any greater or any worse because he won or didnt win the Heisman Trophy. Ditto Peyton.

 

[Ed MOTHEREFFING G]

that's a silly comparison. Tom Brady's career isnt any greater or any worse because he won or didnt win the Heisman Trophy. Ditto Peyton.

its really not

 

[Trip]

its really not

If Manziel's career continues on the path its on you think anyone cares he won the Heisman?

 

[Ed MOTHEREFFING G]

If Manziel's career continues on the path its on you think anyone cares he won the Heisman?

if he became russell wilson's backup you think anyone cares if he wins a superbowl?

the heisman SHOWS that woodson achieved at EVERY level

 

[Trip]

if he became russell wilson's backup you think anyone cares if he wins a superbowl?

I dont see how that's relevant. We're talking about guys who get on the field no? It does prop Woodson's legacy slightly but he's obviously a first ballot HOF'er with or without winning the Heisman.