theworldismine13
God Emperor of SOHH
i think maybe you need to sit down breh
Whose economic views and vision do you most agree with?
- Thread starter Dusty Bake Activate
- Start date
i think maybe you need to sit down breh
Why? Because you have no real response to my simple point?
I think maybe you need to actually read Marx before commenting on something like this.
ogc163
Superstar
Hayek didn't believe in any form of welfarism, he believed government should do NOTHING? That's news to me.
theworldismine13
God Emperor of SOHH
Why? Because you have no real response to my simple point?
I think maybe you need to actually read Marx before commenting on something like this.
because you admit it wont work, i dont think i need to read marx, i think i need to look at the results of people that tried to put his ideas into effect
Julius Skrrvin
I be winkin' through the scope
The fukk. You've never read Marx, not even for school or anything and you're always on a crusade against his work?
Typical Coli Posters
I bet you guys hang out in coffee shops and talk about organic farming and white privilege.
"Yeah bro, the flyover state "wrong type of white people" are totally ruining this country, if only they could study fine art at an elite north eastern university like us good white people"
I bet you guys hang out in coffee shops and talk about organic farming and white privilege.
"Yeah bro, the flyover state "wrong type of white people" are totally ruining this country, if only they could study fine art at an elite north eastern university like us good white people"
I didn't "admit" anything. I said I didn't think it would work. And looking at results would be reasonable, if people were trying to put his ideas into effect. Again- Leninism, Stalinism, Maoism, Castroism, etc, are their own entities. Sociologically, putting them within the broader category of Marxism, conceived as an umbrella term, is one thing, but this thread concerns the ideas of Marx himself, so Marxism in this thread refers to the ideas of Marx- not those of these others.
No, he hasn't. It's clear from him repeating blatantly false assertions again and again. He hasn't even read the works of the thinkers he actually does claim to endorse, last time I checked. Hopefully he fixed that, at least.
theworldismine13
God Emperor of SOHH
you mean the actual communist manifesto, no i havent read it
i have wikipedia and i sleep at holiday inn
ogc163
Superstar
While I agree with this sentiment, I only hope that is this courtesy is extended to the other thinkers in the poll...because I already see some caricature driven posts in relation to the influence/ideas of the economists in the poll.
theworldismine13
God Emperor of SOHH
im agreeing with you, marx's idea wont work
Typical Coli Posters
I bet you guys hang out in coffee shops and talk about organic farming and white privilege.
"Yeah bro, the flyover state "wrong type of white people" are totally ruining this country, if only they could study fine art at an elite north eastern university like us good white people"
interesting.
the thread topic is what idea do you agree with and Marxism by it description is the most humane and progressive idea for humanity. It sounds the best and seems the most ideal for a Utopian society.
Agreed. The description of Hayek should be edited to reflect his endorsement of specific forms of government involvement and social safety nets. I didn't actually read the first post closely.
Hopefully you also agree that you were completely wrong in your No True Scotsman argument and that criticizing an idea without actually knowing what it entails is embarrassing.
theworldismine13
God Emperor of SOHH
yeah it sounds the best, but as the real said, who btw is also an expert on the subject, it wont work
no prob, that sounds like a deal, ill admit to that now that you have admitted that marxism wont work
Dusty Bake Activate
Fukk your corny debates
He did think the government should do nothing to interfere in markets correct?
As far as welfare, I shouldn't have said none, but I think he was ambiguous and contradictory. I know he spoke about the need for wealthy nations to provide some basic minimum of food and "social insurance" (I'm on my phone, don't feel like pulling up the quote), which he later retracted, and he opposed social security and Medicare. So it's hard to identify what forms of social welfare Hayek would support, if any.
Last edited: