Yeah she was called a really good wrestler upon her first entry in the WWE as a face when she beat Nikki but everyone was bashing her on her face promos and now since she's heel, she's the best thing since heel Trish? Absurd. It's much easier being a heel than a face..you have to work comeback matches as a face and have to walk a line on the mic and they get heat for it online while Charlotte and Alexa get praised to no end. It's pretty silly. Is Charlotte better than Becky or Sasha? Not by a long shot....the reason why we are talking about the women's matches so fervently is because of the near 5 star ratings of Sasha and Bayley in back to back matches and when Becky got a standing ovation LOSING to Sasha a couple of months before that. That's why it's a JOKE to see Sasha pushed aside...the fans were chanting WE WANT SASHA all year during her heel run on Raw and popped HUGE for her at Rumble, Mania, and everything else but it's like those factors dont apply to Charlotte.
You call it "believable". Everyone else will call it favorable booking..same thing we get with Reigns, Rollins, and certain others.