On New Year's Eve 2015, Knight Pulliam became engaged to retired National Football League player Edgerton Hartwell.[9][10] They were married the next day, January 1, 2016, in Knight Pulliam's Atlanta home.[11] Hartwell filed for divorce on July 25, 2016.[12] On January 23, 2017, Knight Pulliam gave birth to a daughter, named Ella Grace Hartwell-Pulliam.[13][14] The divorce was finalized in April 2018.[15]She became engaged to Brad James in December 2020