Wow, this is one of the biggest lies I've seen on this board to date. Just straight up fiction.
Punk was, in all metrics (ratings, crowd reaction, merch sales, etc.), the number two babyface in the company right up until he left. And arguably was reaching for number one for a time in 2011. And even when he was getting his heat killed by the Triple H/Nash/Laurinaitis fiasco, his reactions were not affected much at all. Dude was, as I said, top level in every metric that mattered.
I know the board hates Punk now, but can we please stop with the fictions regarding his status. You guys are worse than Vince was with Warrior.