She was the whole package at a time when the women were either there for a check or had nothing to work with. What's sad is that she (and Paige, to some extent) left the company right around the time the women's division was about to change forever. She never got to be around the best competition, never got to refine her skills and reach her highest level. She only had two years you can look back on, so you can't place her in the GOAT category off that.
If she comes back, it will be worth it in the beginning because of all the eras she missed out on and the fact that she's stayed away for this long. But she's going to have to deliver a banger or two or else, there's going to be a lot of talk about whether or not she was ever that good.