Are Jewish people a race or religion??

JadeB

la force de l'avenir
Joined
Apr 2, 2017
Messages
8,947
Reputation
-934
Daps
28,287
It's an ethnic group and a religion made out of several "races". Since race is subjective and a social construct- the definition changes from nation to nation and region to region. For example, Jews are seen as a separate race in Europe while in the US; Jews are seen as only an ethnicity.
 

Anhur

All Star
Joined
Oct 31, 2017
Messages
506
Reputation
2,865
Daps
2,716
Judaism is a religion and Jews practice that religion. The "Children of Isreal" is considered an ethnicity.
The Children of Isreal have varying phenotypes that range from African to Middle Eastern phenotypes.
The European Jews (Ashkenazi/ Sephardic) are Jews (religiously) but not the Children of Isreal.
 
Last edited:

Ms.CuriousCat

All Star
Joined
Mar 7, 2014
Messages
4,117
Reputation
1,040
Daps
8,641
Depends who you ask and what their angle is.

Judaism is a religion. Anyone should be able to convert into a religion for it to be a real religion otherwise it's probably more like a cultural faith where the creator they believe in only made those specific people and everyone else is outside that bubble of existence.

If people who practise Judaism are Jewish then it's a religion.

However the complexity is the ethnicity. Jacob the son of Isaac, the son of Abraham was named "Israel" therefore his descendants regardless of their religion would be "Israelites". Jacob had 12 sons and those are the 12 tribes (the children of Israel). Today Israelites means Jewish and Jewish means Israelites. Also lots of Jews are Caucasian, that is not ethnically Israelite.

Technical ethnic Israelites are a lot of different religions including Muslim and Christian.

However today politically the two are combined it's a religion, it's a culture, it's an ethnicity. In reality it can't be all of those things at the same time, but in practice and in politics that's how it's portrayed.
 

Ghpstface

Kanye West fan
Joined
Nov 2, 2012
Messages
7,863
Reputation
1,505
Daps
21,803
Reppin
Ice Cream Castle
Depends who you ask and what their angle is.

Judaism is a religion. Anyone should be able to convert into a religion for it to be a real religion otherwise it's probably more like a cultural faith where the creator they believe in only made those specific people and everyone else is outside that bubble of existence.

If people who practise Judaism are Jewish then it's a religion.

However the complexity is the ethnicity. Jacob the son of Isaac, the son of Abraham was named "Israel" therefore his descendants regardless of their religion would be "Israelites". Jacob had 12 sons and those are the 12 tribes (the children of Israel). Today Israelites means Jewish and Jewish means Israelites. Also lots of Jews are Caucasian, that is not ethnically Israelite.

Technical ethnic Israelites are a lot of different religions including Muslim and Christian.

However today politically the two are combined it's a religion, it's a culture, it's an ethnicity. In reality it can't be all of those things at the same time, but in practice and in politics that's how it's portrayed.
So you think Abraham was a real person?
 

Brolic Scholar

Licensed Text Technician
Joined
Nov 28, 2015
Messages
5,151
Reputation
4,175
Daps
41,692
Reppin
Unknown Side Effects
Jews come in all races. That’s like asking what race are Catholics? The Jews that most people associate with Judaism in the US are white Europeans.
 

TallMan_J

Retired from TheColi
Bushed
Joined
Nov 21, 2016
Messages
8,701
Reputation
1,301
Daps
31,494
Reppin
Retired
The “Jews” that most of society recognizes today are nothing but whites of European descent or a mix of “Arab”.

In other words, they respesent a stolen identity. The real “Jews” are Hebrew Israelites. They come in many shades of brown.

The people that occupy Israel and claim Judaism right now are imposters. The “Synagogue of Satan”.


Need I continue?
 

Devilinurear

Veteran
Joined
May 1, 2012
Messages
26,516
Reputation
5,682
Daps
86,964
Reppin
NULL
The “Jews” that most of society recognizes today are nothing but whites of European descent or a mix of “Arab”.

In other words, they respesent a stolen identity. The real “Jews” are Hebrew Israelites. They come in many shades of brown.

The people that occupy Israel and claim Judaism right now are imposters. The “Synagogue of Satan”.


Need I continue?
Please do
 

JadeB

la force de l'avenir
Joined
Apr 2, 2017
Messages
8,947
Reputation
-934
Daps
28,287
The “Jews” that most of society recognizes today are nothing but whites of European descent or a mix of “Arab”.

In other words, they respesent a stolen identity. The real “Jews” are Hebrew Israelites. They come in many shades of brown.

The people that occupy Israel and claim Judaism right now are imposters. The “Synagogue of Satan”.


Need I continue?
Depends who you ask and what their angle is.

Judaism is a religion. Anyone should be able to convert into a religion for it to be a real religion otherwise it's probably more like a cultural faith where the creator they believe in only made those specific people and everyone else is outside that bubble of existence.

If people who practise Judaism are Jewish then it's a religion.

However the complexity is the ethnicity. Jacob the son of Isaac, the son of Abraham was named "Israel" therefore his descendants regardless of their religion would be "Israelites". Jacob had 12 sons and those are the 12 tribes (the children of Israel). Today Israelites means Jewish and Jewish means Israelites. Also lots of Jews are Caucasian, that is not ethnically Israelite.

Technical ethnic Israelites are a lot of different religions including Muslim and Christian.

However today politically the two are combined it's a religion, it's a culture, it's an ethnicity. In reality it can't be all of those things at the same time, but in practice and in politics that's how it's portrayed.
Depends who you ask and what their angle is.

Judaism is a religion. Anyone should be able to convert into a religion for it to be a real religion otherwise it's probably more like a cultural faith where the creator they believe in only made those specific people and everyone else is outside that bubble of existence.

If people who practise Judaism are Jewish then it's a religion.

However the complexity is the ethnicity. Jacob the son of Isaac, the son of Abraham was named "Israel" therefore his descendants regardless of their religion would be "Israelites". Jacob had 12 sons and those are the 12 tribes (the children of Israel). Today Israelites means Jewish and Jewish means Israelites. Also lots of Jews are Caucasian, that is not ethnically Israelite.



Technical ethnic Israelites are a lot of different religions including Muslim and Christian.

However today politically the two are combined it's a religion, it's a culture, it's an ethnicity. In reality it can't be all of those things at the same time, but in practice and in politics that's how it's portrayed.
Judaism is a religion and Jews practice that religion. The "Children of Isreal" is considered an ethnicity.
The Children of Isreal have varying phenotypes that range from African to Middle Eastern phenotypes.
The European Jews (Ashkenazi/ Sephardic) are Jews (religiously) but not the Children of Isreal.

All ethnic Jews have SOME Middle Eastern ancestry
DNA tester: 75 percent of Jews trace ancestry to Middle East
Ashkenazi Jews are Middle Eastern & European hybrids - Gene Expression
Indian Jews' ancestry linked to Middle Eastern origin | Genetic Literacy Project
DNA ties Ashkenazi Jews to group of just 330 people from Middle Ages
Studies Show Jews’ Genetic Similarity
Stop with the mis-information
 

TallMan_J

Retired from TheColi
Bushed
Joined
Nov 21, 2016
Messages
8,701
Reputation
1,301
Daps
31,494
Reppin
Retired
Please do


You sure they didn’t look like this?
:sas1: :mjpls:

disciple-philip-icons-of-the-bible.jpg


jethro-icons-of-the-bible.jpg


KING-SOLOMON.jpg


tamar-icons-of-the-bible.jpg


BH.jpg




disciple-judas-icons-of-the-bible.jpg
 

JadeB

la force de l'avenir
Joined
Apr 2, 2017
Messages
8,947
Reputation
-934
Daps
28,287
You sure they didn’t look like this?
:sas1: :mjpls:

disciple-philip-icons-of-the-bible.jpg


jethro-icons-of-the-bible.jpg


KING-SOLOMON.jpg


tamar-icons-of-the-bible.jpg


BH.jpg




disciple-judas-icons-of-the-bible.jpg
Yeah, they looked like Middle Easterners at first. The ones that left the Middle East mixed with the general population of whoever lived there. And the ones that stayed in the Middle East, remained to look like Middle Easterners.
 
Top