If every NFL team played a season with their all-time best roster, who would win the SB?

[Professor Emeritus]

I didn't know Bob coached the 49ers. I read some where they once had a head coach named Bill but he wasn't really all that.

I drop all that and all you have to say is getting on me for one typo.

And Walsh changed the fukking game. I know this is a minority opinion but I actually think Montana wasn't going to be all that, Young was better, it's just that Montana stepped in right as Walsh was introducing an offense that was changing the entire league and Joe happened to be the perfect QB for it.

This nikka really tried to claim Larry Allen for the Niners.

Way to comment on a thread without reading the fukking rules breh, you don't "claim" a player for any team, everyone gets the guys who played for their squad at the level they were at when they played for it..

If all 32 NFL teams played one season with rosters comprised of their all-time best players (including those who played for different teams and best coach in team history) who would win?

Imagine that all-time 49ers team Montana, Lott, Rice, Vernon Davis, Craig/Gore, TO or Pats.. Brady, Gronk, Ty Law, Rodney Harrison, Revis, Moss, Asante, and

Are we taking them at their performance levels for the year they played for the team?

Such as not using a prime Adrian Peterson if it is the Redskins.

Yeah, so prime Rice wouldn’t count for Seahawks or prime Deion for Ravens

Says right on the first page that players who played for other teams count, you just can only count them in the form they played for your team on. Larry Allen had a Pro Bowl season with the Niners. Still, it was probably his worst Pro Bowl season so if you notice I didn't even put him in the starting lineup.

Talking about Allen as a Niner no different than talking about Bron as a Laker.

 

[Scottie Drippin]

Combining the 80s and 00s Giants pass rush and these dudes talking about wide receivers

Ain't no offense breathing against LT and Strahan.

 

[malbaker86]

Niners
Patriots
Ravens
Rams
Cowboys

Are the only answers

 

[malbaker86]

On the flip side worst teams will be Texans, Jags and Panthers. They are probably finishing close to 0-16 (0-17 now...). The only wins the Jags and Texans will get is against each other.

Boselli
Freddy T
Henderson
Stroud
MJD
Smith
McCardell
Hardy
Ramsey
Searcy
Campbell

That's a strong lineup but yea, lack of history kills our starting line up on the OL and at LB

 

[supertrekker]

I drop all that and all you have to say is getting on me for one typo..

Bull or Byll is a typo not Bob.

 

[Johnny Kilroy]

Just gimme the 85 Bears plus Khalil Mack.

 

[Professor Emeritus]

Bull or Byll is a typo not Bob.

What is that even supposed to mean? You've never been typed fast due to muscle memory and punched out a different word than what you were thinking?

I even think I know where the typo came from. When I was a kid the same year Walsh won his 3rd Super Bowl, A's went to the World Series with Bob Welch rolling on a 27-6 Cy Young season. Old brain is just pushing names together now.

 

[klientel]

Combining the 80s and 00s Giants pass rush and these dudes talking about wide receivers

Ain't no offense breathing against LT and Strahan.

That’s true but it might not even matter.

But can Eli consistently beat other insanely stacked defenses? Even in his prime he was never considered elite

 

[T.he I.nformant]

Only way you can have legit argument about something like this is for people to be reasonable.

Brehs asking if Adrian Peterson can be a Redskin
9ers fans saying Primetime is on their squad

Where is the honesty?

 

[dezert_storm]

Surprised no one has mentioned the Broncos, they’d have a decent squad.. Champ Bailey, Talib, Lynch, Atwater, Miller, Terrell Davis, Portis, Peyton/Elway, Shannon Sharpe, Rod Smith, McCaffrey

 

[T.he I.nformant]

Surprised no one has mentioned the Broncos, they’d have a decent squad.. Champ Bailey, Talib, Lynch, Atwater, Miller, Terrell Davis, Portis, Peyton/Elway, Shannon Sharpe, Rod Smith, McCaffrey

Peyton’s a Colt

Elway’s the all-time QB for Denver

And yeah, Denver would be a problem...but I think you could say that for most teams

 

[Supreme365]

On the flip side worst teams will be Texans, Jags and Panthers. They are probably finishing close to 0-16 (0-17 now...). The only wins the Jags and Texans will get is against each other.

mvp cam, smitty, Musin Muhammad, Stephen Davis in the back field, Greg Olsen at TE
Peppers and Luke Kuechly on D
panthers gonna win some games

most franchises never had a an reach cams level in 2015 and he did that without receivers

 

[BucciMane]

Niners
Patriots
Ravens
Rams
Cowboys

Are the only answers

Ravens would have a lot of great defensive players, but the QB position (Jackson has only had one year and McNair is an Oiler), but they don't have the offensive fire-power. I wasn't really thinking the Patriots, but if we are taking players from seasons that they played with said respective team, then I would roll something like this out for the Patriots.


QB: Brady

HB: Curtis Martin, Faulk/White

WR: Moss, Welker, Edelman, Glenn, Tippett

TE: Gronk, Coates (beast), and Murderer


Then you have OL such as John Hannah (GOAT), Mankins, Lights, Armstrong



Defense would be really good too, especially the secondary.

Law, Gillmore, Revis, Milloy, McCoutry and Harrison..




Good luck stopping those WR's and TE's. Probably the most unarguable WR and TE on the same team..

 

[Supreme365]

Who y'all qb for Tampa

jameis

 

[Supreme365]

It’s sad that some of these franchises have never had a great qb