If every NFL team played a season with their all-time best roster, who would win the SB?

dtownreppin214

l'immortale
Supporter
Joined
Apr 30, 2012
Messages
56,802
Reputation
10,872
Daps
195,484
Reppin
Shags & Leathers
Way to comment on a thread without reading the fukking rules breh, you don't "claim" a player for any team, everyone gets the guys who played for their squad at the level they were at when they played for it..
If you are putting 49ers version of Larry Allen (he got the Pro Bowl off his rep) in the discussion for your all-time team then y'all not staying within 10 pts of the Boys. That would be like me considering someone like Ronald Leary for a spot. :childplease:
 

Floyd Pinkerton

Superstar
Supporter
Joined
Mar 29, 2014
Messages
7,642
Reputation
1,680
Daps
22,191
I'll take the Vikings against anybody

All Day and the GOAT Moss on the same offense with Fran Tarkenton at QB.:wow:

With Cris Carter, Ahmad Rashad, Robert Smith, Percy Harvin as well:ehh:

Their D-line would be ridiculous John Randle, Jared Allen, Chris Doleman, the Purple People Eaters:damn:

Joey Browner and Harrison Smith at the safeties too:gladbron:

Then again we might miss a FG and blow it or some shyt:martin:

Where's the Daunte love brehbreh :troll:

For real though y'all might have the most stacked non-SB winning franchise in this format :ehh:
 

Professor Emeritus

Veteran
Poster of the Year
Supporter
Joined
Jan 5, 2015
Messages
51,331
Reputation
19,940
Daps
204,145
Reppin
the ether
If you are putting 49ers version of Larry Allen (he got the Pro Bowl off his rep) in the discussion for your all-time team then y'all not staying within 10 pts of the Boys. That would be like me considering someone like Ronald Leary for a spot. :childplease:
We have two fantastic all-time HOF Tackles already and plenty of All-Pro interior linemen who have won racks of super bowls, we'll be fine.

Who's your QB? :mjlol:

Think your receivers can touch ours? :russ:

And our defense is better than yours too. :ahh:
 

supertrekker

Superstar
Joined
Aug 10, 2015
Messages
7,633
Reputation
175
Daps
18,423
What is that even supposed to mean? You've never been typed fast due to muscle memory and punched out a different word than what you were thinking? :dahell:

I even think I know where the typo came from. When I was a kid the same year Walsh won his 3rd Super Bowl, A's went to the World Series with Bob Welch rolling on a 27-6 Cy Young season. Old brain is just pushing names together now. :flabbynsick:

just breaking balls breh
 

Art Barr

INVADING SOHH CHAMPION
Joined
Apr 30, 2012
Messages
72,640
Reputation
15,467
Daps
101,077
Reppin
CHICAGO
I'll take the Vikings against anybody

All Day and the GOAT Moss on the same offense with Fran Tarkenton at QB.:wow:

With Cris Carter, Ahmad Rashad, Robert Smith, Percy Harvin as well:ehh:

Their D-line would be ridiculous John Randle, Jared Allen, Chris Doleman, the Purple People Eaters:damn:

Joey Browner and Harrison Smith at the safeties too:gladbron:

Then again we might miss a FG and blow it or some shyt:martin:


the championship spirit of the people eaters.
still would not get them past the curse of the nfc title game.


art barr
 

Art Barr

INVADING SOHH CHAMPION
Joined
Apr 30, 2012
Messages
72,640
Reputation
15,467
Daps
101,077
Reppin
CHICAGO
Don't slouch on the Niners defense. very underrated. I'd take the Niners in that game


I am a Steelers fan through and through.

yet the old curse of the afc would settle in.
where regardless of smy close score.
joe Montana would break my heart all over again.
like the golden boy always did versus the afc finalist like usual.
plus, in heroic fashhion win that game.

that I do know.


only people beating Montana is all time bears, and giants.



art barr
 

Art Barr

INVADING SOHH CHAMPION
Joined
Apr 30, 2012
Messages
72,640
Reputation
15,467
Daps
101,077
Reppin
CHICAGO
Damn how could I forget about the raiders :wow: they would be great too EDIT: take Khalil Mack off this list :russ:he is a bear now and will be for the rest of his career :ufdup:


yup,...

can't stop that all time bears defense.
nor all time offense with Walter, gale, willie, Dennis gentry and hester.
I got mad fb's all time from muster to suey.
I even got tb's from raymont Harris to neal Anderson.

plus dark horse receivers and hated on Ditka era qb's from Pt Willis to Doug Flutie and CAPTAIN COMEBACK...BEFORE HE CAME BACK!

none of them gettin tick over dead eye tho.



art barr

DA BEARS.
if you want a get snazzy.
I can run Walter at qb and gale at tail back.

no bullshyt
 

supertrekker

Superstar
Joined
Aug 10, 2015
Messages
7,633
Reputation
175
Daps
18,423
I am a Steelers fan through and through.

yet the old curse of the afc would settle in.
where regardless of smy close score.
joe Montana would break my heart all over again.
like the golden boy always did versus the afc finalist like usual.
plus, in heroic fashhion win that game.

that I do know.


only people beating Montana is all time bears, and giants.



art barr

Bears and Giants no way. Bears history is Gayle Sayers and the 85 team. Giants are a non dynasty version of the Patriots. A hand full of hall of famers and many good replaceable players.
 
Last edited:

3rd Koast Kang

Superstar
Joined
Nov 15, 2014
Messages
4,435
Reputation
900
Daps
16,678
Pretty good thread :ehh:

Y’all boys gotta read the rules though and not catch feelings :mjlol:

Off the top of my head the most stacked teams


Niners
Steelers
Rams
Cowboys
Vikings


There’s only a handful of teams whose all time rosters are laughable
 

dtownreppin214

l'immortale
Supporter
Joined
Apr 30, 2012
Messages
56,802
Reputation
10,872
Daps
195,484
Reppin
Shags & Leathers
We have two fantastic all-time HOF Tackles already and plenty of All-Pro interior linemen who have won racks of super bowls, we'll be fine.

Who's your QB? :mjlol:

Think your receivers can touch ours? :russ:

And our defense is better than yours too. :ahh:

Cowboys: Oline, Dline, RB, TE, DB

49ers: QB, S

Push: LB, WR
 

Professor Emeritus

Veteran
Poster of the Year
Supporter
Joined
Jan 5, 2015
Messages
51,331
Reputation
19,940
Daps
204,145
Reppin
the ether
Cowboys: Oline, Dline, RB, TE, DB

49ers: QB, S

Push: LB, WR

:usure:

Our defense would SWAMP you

You'd have to stack your D-line with drug addicts, old cast-offs from our team, and white guys from the 70s.

Your linebackers would be white guys from the 60s or a guy who couldn't even make our starting lineup.

Our safety is one of the greatest defensive players of all time and miles ahead of anyone you'd field

Our corners are a better version of Deion than yours and a HOFer

We're literally better than you at defense at every level.



On offense you have RBs and OL. Gotta give your OL credit but RBs don't decide anything anymore.

Our QBs are light years ahead of yours and QBs are the game.

Vernon Davis is every bit as good a football player as Jay Novacek - Davis is a much better blocker than Novacek, a far better athlete downfield, and just as good a pass-catcher. Novacek just played for better teams and better QBs so he racked up stats.

And you ranked your WRs with ours? :comeon: We have TWO receivers better than the cokehead in your #1 slot. :mjlol:
 

8WON6

The Great Negro
Supporter
Joined
Nov 7, 2015
Messages
70,535
Reputation
15,128
Daps
282,963
Reppin
Kansas City, MO.
:yeshrug:

Mahomes
Hill
Kelce
Jamaal Charles(sub in ...Marcus Allen/Priest Holmes/Larry Johnson/Okoye)
Dante Hall
Tony Gonzalez
Willie Roaf/Will Shields/Brian Waters/Weigman/John Alt

Neil Smith/Chris Jones/Jared Allen
Derrick Thomas/Derrick Johnson/Tamba Hali/Justin Houston

Eric Berry/Honey Badger/Dale Carter/Emmit Thomas
 
Top