Is this player a Basketball Hall of Famer?

[Ed MOTHERFUCKING G]

• 2x NBA Champion
• NBA All rookie team
• 2x all defensive ream
• Made playoffs 10/11 straight seasons on different teams
• NCAA Championship
• Most Outstanding Player of title game
• National player of the year
• Consensus all America first team and second team
• 3x NCAA DPOY
• Conference POY
• Academic all American
• Collegiate jersey retired
• Naismith prep POY
• First team hs all American
• Mr. Basketball

First decide if he's a basketball hall of famer

Second guess who he is, and spoiler it. Rep for the first good guess

 

[Justise M]

Yes by today's standard

Spoiler

Shane Battier

should be in the HOF

 

[firemanBk]

I voted GTFO but since it's basketball in general and not solely NBA idk

Spoiler

Battier was a beat in college but he was a flat role player as a pro. Honestly maybe a bit early as a 3 & D prototype idk.

 

[BaggerofTea]

if you include his college resume, yes.

just his professional resume, no way.

Honestly the college resume is probably enough to get it, that pro outlook is disappointing

 

[get these nets]

Yes, the anti-receeding hairline guy will get in. Everybody gets in eventually.

 

[SchoolboyC]

College Basketball Hall of Fame, yes. He didn’t do enough as a pro. Even at his absolute peak I’m not even sure if he was a top 50 player

 

[Ed MOTHERFUCKING G]

if you include his college resume, yes.

just his professional resume, no way.

Honestly the college resume is probably enough to get it, that pro outlook is disappointing

I mean he was never gonna be that guy. It's wild that he and Chris Webber have like a 1 game difference in college resume, went to the same HS, but Webber has 3x the NBA career

 

[Ed MOTHERFUCKING G]

College Basketball Hall of Fame, yes. He didn’t do enough as a pro. Even at his absolute peak I’m not even sure if he was a top 50 player

Basketball Hall of Fame isn't just NBA hof

 

[obarth]

10/11 "straight seasons"? How does that work?

 

[Cladyclad]

No

no all star appearances or all nba teams

so I’m out

 

[BigMoneyGrip]

Without the college resume nah he not a HOF player

 

[SchoolboyC]

Basketball Hall of Fame isn't just NBA hof

It isn’t but name me a player in the Basketball HOF who played the majority of their career in the NBA and never made an All-Star or All-NBA team, never won DPOY or even 1st team All-Defense and never averaged 15 PPG

 

[Ed MOTHERFUCKING G]

Without the college resume nah he not a HOF player

Well he does have that resume so...

 

[boskey]

I got it right!

 

[Braman]

Basketball Hall of Fame isn't just NBA hof

This is the most misinterpreted thing

There is already a college hall of fame

So we don’t have to pretend that a college career has equal—-or really any—-weight to the ‘basketball’ hall of fame. If it did Christian Laetner gets in the hall before Battier. As would Bobby Hurley. Larry Johnson. NBA Hall of famer Matean cleaves Like cmon now