I'm with you here. Goodz has his own special category.. but who the hell really listens to three rounds of him and comes out thinking he was dope through and through? He's pretty much a gimmick battler. I already spoke on the weirdness of grown men being charmed by his "swag."
Whether or not the pen dudes (or as
@theflyest puts it.. "pen" guys

) are on the Lux performance level, I truly believe we're more likely to get a memorable and competitive battle than some forced old guard v. old guard shyt. So long as the newer dude doesn't choke, anyway.
Goodz is a very effective battle rapper and not everyone's cup of tea.
As far as "pen" guys, I still view them in a couple of different categories.
Pen guys that can perform well:
Lux
Verb
Big T
Daylyt
Maybe O-Red, but the URL stopped fukking with him after the Big T battle. Lost to Hitman on UDubb.
Pen guys:
JC
Chilla Jones (show glimpses he can perform on a big stage)
Born
Etc
With Lux expressing he would entertain JC in a room, battling a "pen" guy now becomes more interesting. However, I think he was just speaking out of frustration after those tweets from his peers. This is still a business and he knows where the money is at.
My lack of interest in Lux battling a "pen guy" has always stemmed from knowing it would take place on a large stage. I just don't think those guys can hold down those kind of rooms, which is why they are typically mid tier. I'm not a fan of lopsided battles and a Loaded Lux vs JC in a Irving Plaza is some lopsided shyt. Now in a room? You have a real battle for the fans.
Hell, even the guys that can perform well in a large room CAN lose the crowd. You really have to dumb it down and cater to that audience.