Everyone on this list is a good poster.
puppetmaster - Quality posts as always.
DaylitoJames - Holds down the live threads and always brings the comedy. I also enjoy his posts outside of TSC.
mrken12 - Quality posts and always has interesting takes & points even if I don't always agree with them.
2 Cold Taurus - I really enjoy the BWIW threads because it's brought out a lot of good discussion and unintentional comedy. I always enjoy reading his takes because they make me laugh more often than not.
Heelish - One of my favorites. No one can touch his ability to give any wrestler a nickname
I'll give the nod to
@DaylitoJames since he should've won it last year. Don't drop the ball otherwise I'll get my Lesnar on and take it back next year