Come on now fam, I've stated repeatedly that Bernie's rhetoric on reparations is a failure. What I'm trying to do is delineate the difference between Bernie on reparations and Bernie on addressing the African American community with his actual policies. I'll point back to the 5 minutes or so of discussion about how Bernie will help African Americans before the reparations question even comes up. I don't get why everyone leads off with addressing income inequality if they're only concerned with the cash payment. Charlemagne started with economic empowerment; the town hall question linked reparations to income inequality too. It's not disingenuous to respond with a literal concept for addressing income inequality just because he's not offering a check Andrew Yang style. When people ask him specifically about the cash payout, he says "nah, I've got better ways to help" and you can disagree that they are better. But to paint him as disingenuous or bad on racial issues is unfair.
I really think this comes down to what the goal is reparations when you ask about it. If your only focus is the cash payout, then I understand attacking Bernie like he's fronting. But if you're focused on the income inequality aspect, then he is addressing your concern every time he brings up expanding 10 20 30. And just to circle back to it, I think HR 40 and Booker's mirror version is a great idea and one that every candidate should endorse but that should not be enough in an honest conversation about addressing racial wealth gaps or systemic racism. The reason I take Bernie and Warren over every other candidate regardless of how well they dodges the actual reparations concept is because they have legislation throughout their platforms to address things like systemic racism. Bernie's GnD applies that Clyburn plan and I'd argue his Justice Reform plan beats out everyone else's although tbh I haven't taken deep dives into every candidates. His Universal Programs naturally will help as well. So if we're talking reparations alone...yeah his answers kinda suck. They're the most honest of the bunch, but that comes with pissing people off unnecessarily. But if we want to focus on the actual intended outcome of reparations, shrinking the racial wealth gap, then I'll put Bernie up there with the top platforms focusing on that goal. That's my main point.