King Kreole

natural blondie like goku
Joined
Mar 8, 2014
Messages
16,436
Reputation
4,548
Daps
44,709
if the doctor is getting a pay cut you’re going to have to cut the wage of nurses too. I make about $175000 with OT. I’m just saying.
Average RN makes $73K, so definitely not as egregiously high as doctors, but yes, there is bloat almost everywhere in the healthcare system.
 

dora_da_destroyer

Master Baker
Joined
May 1, 2012
Messages
65,923
Reputation
16,494
Daps
271,428
Reppin
Oakland
Start with whatever you want. Insurers. Pharma. Medical devices. Hospitals. You're still gonna end up at this same doctor conundrum.

Y'all acting like doctors are some especially aggrieved class, consigned to the gutters by an ungrateful society. These people, by and large, are NOT struggling, they can take the fukkin cut. :stopitslime:
Lol @ proposing a plan that says hey “we’re going to cut the pay of a whole profession”...one that actually provides value at that :dead:

Ok
 

Pressure

#PanthersPosse
Supporter
Joined
Nov 19, 2016
Messages
47,219
Reputation
7,216
Daps
150,142
Reppin
CookoutGang
What we're doing is taking a holistic look at healthcare costs and seeing why they're so exorbitantly high compared to other countries that do the same thing.
That's fine and that is to be expected. Hence the question, why are you choosing Healthcare professionals salaries?
There are many contributing factors, but the fact that doctors in America are getting paid far, far more than their counterparts in other countries is a load-bearing factor.
I get where you're coming from I do. And this largely applies to general practitioners. IMHO it's an easier sell to use more NP and require less in person visits to handle routine care as a better solution.

We can disagree here though as it isn't too important to the overall position imo.

You either continue to subsidize the high quality of life for doctors or you create a healthcare system that covers everybody without soaking the middle class in taxes and doesn't attract fortune-seekers. If you go into medicine for the ethics and to help people, then you shouldn't be whining when you're asked to no longer be the highest paid profession in society.
This is where we will disagree completely.

1. Doctors high pay is largely a result of the high cost of education in this country and the high cost of starting a practice.

200 thousand dollars tables, 300k degrees, etc. If you want to cut cost you need to cut the cost of entry. If you don't many of these people will move into other Stem degrees that require less education and pay more.

2. Doctors are almost always the highest paid in societies you use as justification for why our doctors should make less. This is something you have to reconcile.
 

Pressure

#PanthersPosse
Supporter
Joined
Nov 19, 2016
Messages
47,219
Reputation
7,216
Daps
150,142
Reppin
CookoutGang
If it wasn’t for nursing there would be revolution in this country.
Nurses are underpaid. They do the majority of the heavy lifting for patients. They're required to be skilled, multifaceted, unflappable, talked down to, and setup their doctor and thus the hospital for success.

They should be paid more, especially in the ER and childcare.

If you can afford healthcare the US has some of the best Healthcare in the country.

If the argument is US med workers salaries cost 100bn a year more than Germany then we have a space to fix that. Lower the defense budget. Why are we raising it when everyone is saying we're pulling out of these expensive occupations.
 

NY's #1 Draft Pick

Veteran
Supporter
Joined
Apr 30, 2012
Messages
30,852
Reputation
6,680
Daps
100,786
Reppin
305
Medical School tuition costs and student debt are both issues that need to be addressed, but ultimately the quality of life for doctors will need to drop if M4A or any form of quality universal healthcare is to be adopted. Medicine shouldn't be an field one goes into to get rich. I don't see a problem with a GP having around the same quality of life as a public defender or teacher (which should go up) and a surgeon having the same as a professor. :yeshrug:
Some careers require more teaching, skills and mental work than others. I’m in the healthcare field so I know what goes on. Imagine being an icu nurse caring for four intubated patients on all types of drips with no tech help . You have these peoples lives in your hands. Imagine dealing with a patients that’s on the verge of crashing and they have multiple organ failure and you have to pick the right meds and perform the right interventions to keep them alive. One fukk up and you’re getting sued. People in America are quick to sue you too.
 

NY's #1 Draft Pick

Veteran
Supporter
Joined
Apr 30, 2012
Messages
30,852
Reputation
6,680
Daps
100,786
Reppin
305
What do you disagree with? That quality of life for doctors will need to drop for M4A to be effectively implemented, or that doctor shouldn't be making 6x what teachers make? Would it be ok for doctors to make 2x what professors make? $200K instead of $300K?

People shouldn't become doctors to get rich, and they will 100% oppose an M4A plan that constrains their pay. But the doctor lobby shouldn't have veto power over what type of healthcare we have. The question is, which option is better for society: doctors having the highest occupational salary + poor people having no/shytty healthcare OR doctors reducing their salary to be in line with their international counterparts + everyone having quality healthcare. If the prime imperative is for America to be a place where doctors can get rich, then the former option makes sense. But if the prime imperative is for America to be a place where everyone gets access to quality healthcare, regardless of their station in life, then the latter option makes sense.
And if doctors are as magnanimous as you say, and people don't go into medicine to get rich, then there shouldn't be pushback from doctors to the latter option.

None of this precludes going after the other sources of bloat in healthcare. In fact, bringing down doctor costs won't solve this alone. But I don't see how this gets solved without doing so. And I wouldn't call teachers or professors or government lawyers low skilled, those are all professions that require post-secondary schooling, some as much as doctors. And I think people in those professions have a right to question why they're subsidizing the doctor's 3rd vacation or country cottage with their taxes, and why the doctor is making 3-5x as much as them. As other countries have shown, that disparity is not some intrinsic, essential facet of practicing medicine.

Breh being a doctor , PA, nurse etc is a 24/7 365 day career. When’s the last time you heard a teacher was on call for a hospital whether it’s for nurses needing orders or to go into surgery. Some doctors are literally in charge of thousands of people’s Heath with their practices. people rely on checkups from Said doctors to stay healthy and live a good life.
Not trying to diminish the jobs other industries do either but you got to realize these jobs take a toll on you. It’s mentally , physically and financially draining. Every year you have to make sure all your credentials are in order every year you have to make sure you have continuing education. Medicine is not a joke.
 

Jhoon

Spontaneous Mishaps and Hijinks
Joined
Jul 2, 2012
Messages
16,518
Reputation
1,495
Daps
37,713
Id be more in favor of raising taxes than cutting pay for those in the medical field in regards to expanded medical coverage
When you compare the salaries of healthcare professionals worldwide to their American counterparts you notice there is a huge divergence between the wages. The new argument is that the wages are the reason why healthcare costs are through the roof?
 

NkrumahWasRight Is Wrong

Veteran
Supporter
Joined
May 1, 2012
Messages
46,331
Reputation
5,935
Daps
94,024
Reppin
Uncertain grounds
When you compare the salaries of healthcare professionals worldwide to their American counterparts you notice there is a huge divergence between the wages. The new argument is that the wages are the reason why healthcare costs are through the roof?

6 Reasons Healthcare Is So Expensive in the U.S.

The example of 1300 billing clerks for a hospital with 900 beds is an example of bloated administrative costs. Wages in the administrative and clerical divisions of healthcare should probably be cut. Not the doctors, PAs or nurses.

Drug prices are also ridiculous. Im currently trying to get off a medication that retails for 3k :dead: thats ludicrous (and also the reason I'm still awake and borderline tweaking :heh:)

My insurance covers it. But once i saw the price i was like fukk that. If i lose insurance for some reason theres no way in hell id afford that so i may as well get off it now
 

King Kreole

natural blondie like goku
Joined
Mar 8, 2014
Messages
16,436
Reputation
4,548
Daps
44,709
Lol @ proposing a plan that says hey “we’re going to cut the pay of a whole profession”...one that actually provides value at that :dead:

Ok
source.gif


It's exactly what Canada did when rolling out their universal healthcare.

The doctor’s strike that nearly killed Canada’s Medicare-for-all plan, explained

Doctors made a stink, went on strike for a couple of weeks, and eventually backed down when the government stood its ground. There are other professions that will need to have their pay cut to enact a more equitable society. If we're already getting squeamish asking doctors to not be the most lucrative profession in society in order to bring about universal healthcare, we absolutely will not have the fortitude to enact any of the progressive policy measures.
 
Top