The problem with this format is that you have a star like Wemby who was dominant, but because his team was eliminated, he played a total less than 20 minutes. Also, just because it worked this year doesn’t mean it will next year. Not every all star game has been close in the past. I know things got out of hand with three point attempts (which I think is the main culprit), but all it takes is one player to play hard and then others will step up in whatever format they choose. I remember when they experimented with the draft and the Elam endings. Those were competitive also until they weren’t.