Don’t get me wrong I know the West was killing it with the sales at the time. But that’s why I made a point to say the West wasn’t killing it musically. It’s not like the West was putting out music that had a superior quality. shyt was right on par which is also why I said much of the popularity from the West had to do with the image and the controversy. White kids ate it up
Also a gimmick isn’t necessarily something that is fake
gim·mick
/ˈɡimik/
Learn to pronounce
noun
1.
a trick or device intended to attract attention, publicity, or business
Coming up with a particular style to separate yourself from the competition isn’t necessarily a bad thing
Dude, Straight Outta Compton, nikkaz4Life, Amerikkka's Most Wanted, Death Certificate, The Chronic, Doggystyle, Original Gangster, & Cypress Hill isn't killing it?
And yeah, gimmick is a "trick" meaning fake to attract attention.
There's a difference between something being your style, and a gimmick which is a fake tactic to gain attention, which is what I said.
Das EFX just were that way. That's who they were. They didn't just do it to get on the pop charts or something. It was their style.
Beastie Boys had 3 of their 4 biggest albums in the 90s, with #1 albums in '94 and '98. You call them "pranksters", that's the point. They were awful rappers with a gimmick and yet they were one of the biggest names in hip hop.
Notice you didn't say anything about MC Hammer or Fresh Prince.
Talking about all the other guys I listed not being respected....it's not like the shytty gimmick rappers today are respected either. They just sell.
The Beastie Boys weren't even played on Rap radio after "License To Ill"
How old are you?
Like The Beasties were for the Lollapalooza crowds moreso than for rap crowds after License To Ill
And still, I'd say that as prankster rappers, not to be taken too seriously, they weren't bad.
Would you say Ol' Dirty b*stard or somebody like old school Busta Rhymes who had a crazy style that was non linear were mediocre or wack?
Not if you know Hip-Hop.
Ask Chuck D, or Run-DMC, or KRS about The Beasties.
The Beasties had their party lane for the first record, then they became the Alternative Rock darlings for the rest of their careers.
I've never heard them on a Black radio station in my life

and I'm almost 40 years old.
And MC Hammer & Fresh Prince are a lot better than some cats today that I've heard going back to Souljah Boy being popular and shyt
I'd take either of them over mumble rappers.
DEFINITELY
THE 90S SEEMS LIKE IT HAD WAYYYY MORE ERAS THAN THE 10S, ITS WEIRD
AND IN 2000 WE WERE LOOKIN AT SHIIT FROM 1989 LIKE IT WAS ANCIENT
NOWADAYS, SHIIT FROM 2009 DOESNT SEEM THAT FAR IN THE PAST TBH
This is so true.
If you break down the 90s it's basically like this
'89-'91 The Transition Era:
The end of the '80s rappers like Run-DMC, PE, Eric B. & Rakim, Big Daddy Kane, etc as top sellers, the beginning of West Coast gangsta rap dominance, and Vanilla Ice, Hammer, Salt-N-Pepa, and Heavy D doing versions of pop rap.
'92-94 West Coast Dominance
Dre, Snoop, Ice Cube, Cypress Hill, Too Short, and the emergence of 2pac had the West selling insane records

, while the East Coast was kind of finding itself with Boom Bap, while Wu-Tang, Nas, Biggie, and Boot Camp are leading the reemergence.
'95-96 East vs. West
Just both coasts kicking all kinds of ass, while The South & The Midwest emerge as real contenders.
'97-99 The End
2pac & Biggie die, gangsta rap dies with them, the emergence of Puffy, Jay, Master P & "Businessman Rap", the bling bling era, & the emergence of South dominance, oh & Eminem & Nelly seize the pop charts.