A deal for Alex Smith has been completed

[Trip]

No it is not..........Not even


Most QBs in the history of the sport were game managers, and there is nothing wrong with that because that is what a QB is supposed to do.....manage the game

who are these game managing QB's in the league right now

 

[FreedS[ohh]lave]

Name the QB thats prolific in snow games.

I remember Kelly and Marino having a shootout in a blizzard in a playoff game in 91

 

[FreedS[ohh]lave]

Geno played in three different systems during his college career. It's not like he's thrown didn't make some tough throws in tight coverage.

He just has spells of bad mechanics that can be coached up. The guy threw 98 TDs and 23 ints for his career.

Id rather a shot at Bridgewater dude has minimal flaws..i think evne Boyd is moving past him

 

[NYC Rebel]

I remember Kelly and Marino having a shootout in a blizzard in a playoff game in 91

1st ballot Hall of famers are your proof?

 

[NYC Rebel]

Id rather a shot at Bridgewater dude has minimal flaws..i think evne Boyd is moving past him

No question....

 

[the white hiphop thief]

Teddy if you told me trading Revis for a pick next year guarantees him i think id do it.


I dont mind Geno but give me Jones or Mingo so we can finally fukk qb's up

 

[Field Marshall Bradley]

who are these game managing QB's in the league right now

Hopefully all of them, because that is the QBs job.

The term is an overused, oversimplified cliche that people use as a back-handed compliment out of ignorance.

 

[Trip]

Hopefully all of them, because that is the QBs job.

The term is an overused, oversimplified cliche that people use as a back-handed compliment out of ignorance.

define managing the game.

Not turning the ball over? The QB's job is to not to that? No fukking shyt.

 

[FreedS[ohh]lave]

Hopefully all of them, because that is the QBs job.

The term is an overused, oversimplified cliche that people use as a back-handed compliment out of ignorance.

So you see no difference in what Manning or Rodgers does as opposed to Alex Smith?

 

[LastEmperor2k2]

Geno is clearly a first round talent. We've done this retread thing with SF numerous times & just got done with it with Matt Cassel. Alex Smith isn't going to lead us anywhere. He was considered a bust before a QB guru like Harbaugh made him look serviceable. After that year Harbaugh still went out & tried to get Peyton Manning to take his spot.

Well he also was considered a top choice QB today with great skills, that's why he was drafted #1 .

And you act like trying to get Peyton is somehow a slight to anybody, that's a top 5 all time QB.

I think Geno may be a 1st round talent, he's nowhere near a #1 overall talent though

 

[Field Marshall Bradley]

define managing the game.

Not turning the ball over? The QB's job is to not to that? No fukking shyt.

You say it like its a small task, but it is not, since turnovers are one of the critical criteria people use in gauging a QB's effectiveness....

Being white and not turning the ball over has parlayed into about 25 million gauranteed over the last 3 years for Alex Smith so evidently it means something

 

[LastEmperor2k2]

No it is not..........Not even


Most QBs in the history of the sport were game managers, and there is nothing wrong with that because that is what a QB is supposed to do.....manage the game

There are guys with great talent who can't be successful because they can't be a game manager.

I love it, it's just one of those dumb ass buzzwords like "Elite" that they throw on a QB so they can put them in a box.

 

[LastEmperor2k2]

Teddy if you told me trading Revis for a pick next year guarantees him i think id do it.


I dont mind Geno but give me Jones or Mingo so we can finally fukk qb's up

But you guys will still have zero offense.

Don't you think part of the Jets problem was the complete focus on defense in many of their drafts?

If they send out the same offense as 2012, why even play

 

[#1 pick]

Id rather a shot at Bridgewater dude has minimal flaws..i think evne Boyd is moving past him

Finishing 8-8, you probably won't have a shot in hell at him.

 

[Trip]

You say it like its a small task, but it is not, since turnovers are one of the critical criteria people use in gauging a QB's effectiveness....

Being white and not turning the ball over has parlayed into about 25 million gauranteed over the last 3 years for Alex Smith so evidently it means something

Not saying its a small task but this is assumed. If you're a QB that constantly turns the ball over you dont last in the league.

In todays NFL if you cant pass the ball effectively down the field and make the intermediate to deeper throws on a rope....you aint winning a title.

I've heard enough of Alex Smith. The Niners were insanely talented the past two years with guys still on their rookie contracts. The switch to Kaep was for the future....because he's 100x more talented than Smith...and their roster will be purged. You cant keep everyone. Kaepernick makes up for other weaker positions with his ability to be a game changer and the most important position.