when did I ever say Payton played one season. I was born in 84 and Im not a Bears fan so why should I care about Bears history. The Thread title is A.P or Walter Payton. I chose A.P. This conversation is over. Deal with it
A.P or Walter payton
- Thread starter ScottyG
- Start date
when did I ever say Payton played one season. I was born in 84 and Im not a Bears fan so why should I care about Bears history. The Thread title is A.P or Walter Payton. I chose A.P. This conversation is over. Deal with it
All Day 
AlbertPullhoez
The Takeover
Who's y'all top 5 backs anyway?
1. Jim Brown
2. Eric dikkerson
3. Adrian Peterson
4. Walter Payton
5. Emmitt Smith
1. Jim Brown
2. Eric dikkerson
3. Adrian Peterson
4. Walter Payton
5. Emmitt Smith
mastermind
Rest In Power Kobe
what are you talking about? all of your post reference when the Bears were good. You made a bizarre statement about Payton not facing 8 or 9 men in the box, and all other nonsense.
The convo has been over because you are ignorant of the past and proud of it.
feelosofer
#ninergang
Thank you, I have to argue with people that weren't even twinkle in their daddy's eyes. People don't realize that he did the same shyt AD did and then some, with less physical talent and less rules with nastier defensive players, with less games played, with less snaps.
Do you realize that AD had to avg 1800 yds for the next 4 seasons, to match Paytons yardage in the same amount of time, do you realize how difficult that is? Like I said AD has a damn good chance of getting but his arms aren't long enough, let's see him stay relatively healthy 2 seasons in a row.
I wouldn't place AP before WP at this point. You have to see a career play out before deeming them GOAT or whatever. Plus, all the great RB's have their own respective places, so I can't say one is greater than the other. Due to the growth of the game, it makes it even harder.
Usually, folks start with Jim Brown and go from there (barely anyone before and a handful since did what he did). That said, if AP keeps up the pace, you could argue a top-5/10 slot, but he's got some work to do in order to catch up with "Sweetness".
Usually, folks start with Jim Brown and go from there (barely anyone before and a handful since did what he did). That said, if AP keeps up the pace, you could argue a top-5/10 slot, but he's got some work to do in order to catch up with "Sweetness".
