Who Was the Better Player In His Prime?

  • Larry Bird

    Votes: 68 41.5%
  • LeBron James

    Votes: 76 46.3%
  • Delonte West Won

    Votes: 20 12.2%

  • Total voters
    164

nieman

Senior Member
Joined
Jun 30, 2012
Messages
17,853
Reputation
2,565
Daps
35,436
Reppin
Philly
Having watched both play, I'd take Bird over LeBron...

:manny:

How can you not? I mean, next to MJ I don't think there's another player in which every defender has hella stories on how he gave them the business. Zeke tellin stories about how Chuck was gettin in they a$$ over letting Bird do them like that, everyone else with stories saying "Bird first said this then did this." Bird walking in a room and shutting up countless ninjas with one statement. Read the stories from Dream Team and how MJ and them were talking and Bird shut Pippen up like "I gave you work", then saying "MJ got next."

Bird is Top 6 (IMO) no way he's past 7 to ever play. He's not even known as an all-around guy and yet he still has multiple seasons of 10rpg & 7apg.
 

I.V.

Keep this Fire
Supporter
Joined
May 7, 2012
Messages
7,056
Reputation
2,220
Daps
17,747
Lebron came out of high school. You're not in your prime when your 22 years old, jackass.

Your prime, in the nba, generally speaking is from 26-29.

Listen --

People USED to consider 26-30 an athlete's prime, because they didn't come out of college until they were 21 or 22 -- and by 26 or 27, they were in their fourth or fifth year pro, but still had some of their athleticism AND the experience to match.

But anybody that follows sports or has worked in the indurstry knows, that for guys that enter the NBA at 18 and 19 - they're prime shifts forward, because they are more athletic, and have fewer miles on their legs at 22-23, But still have the same amount of experience.

LeBron was a far more dominant physical force in 06, 07 than he is now. That's a fact. He's even admitted as much. This season and last season are STATISTICALLY his worst seasons since he was a teenager -- and yet a simple ass poster like you would INCLUDETHEM, after he's logged nearly 50,000 minutes as a part of his prime???


:mjlol: Do math, dummy. Once you've learned a little bit about the sport, then come back to the adult table and try to grab a seat.
 

MalikReloaded

All Star
Joined
Sep 30, 2015
Messages
2,449
Reputation
160
Daps
10,747
Reppin
The 215
Listen --

People USED to consider 26-30 an athlete's prime, because they didn't come out of college until they were 21 or 22 -- and by 26 or 27, they were in their fourth or fifth year pro, but still had some of their athleticism AND the experience to match.

But anybody that follows sports or has worked in the indurstry knows, that for guys that enter the NBA at 18 and 19 - they're prime shifts forward, because they are more athletic, and have fewer miles on their legs at 22-23, But still have the same amount of experience.

LeBron was a far more dominant physical force in 06, 07 than he is now. That's a fact. He's even admitted as much. This season and last season are STATISTICALLY his worst seasons since he was a teenager -- and yet a simple ass poster like you would INCLUDETHEM, after he's logged nearly 50,000 minutes as a part of his prime???


:mjlol: Do math, dummy. Once you've learned a little bit about the sport, then come back to the adult table and try to grab a seat.

Okay. Jackass, I guess Kobe's prime was from 2000-2004 then when he was 22-26 and not from 2005-2008 when he was 27-30. You got it right breh. He was in his prime during the three peat years and the loss against the Pistons. Not when he was cooking entire teams by himself and scoring 50 points a game. Moron. The human body doesn't care when you came into the league. You're at your physical peak as a man at 25....regardless. In the NBA, being at that peak physical point and adding years of experience to go along with it is why they call your mid/late 20s your prime. You're not prime anything at 21/22. Anybody with eyes can tell you Lebron was in his prime in Miami. The numbers don't show it because he was sharing the ball with Wade and Bosh but, his effiency was through the roof.
 

I.V.

Keep this Fire
Supporter
Joined
May 7, 2012
Messages
7,056
Reputation
2,220
Daps
17,747
Okay. Jackass, I guess Kobe's prime was from 2000-2004 then when he was 22-26 and not from 2005-2008 when he was 27-30


I'm going to stop you right there --

Because my point is exactly this: there is not generic "prime" that can be applied to every athlete - for the reasons I described. That is why LeBron's current season doesn't necessarily qualify for his prime. Your prime is determined by the performances you give over the course of your career.

If Lebron suddenly started shooting 58% from 3 over the next three seasons, averaging 40 a game -- then, when he retires... I'd consider that a part of his prime. But given the fact that he's less athletic than he was 5 years ago, and that his current trajectory is pointing to exactly the opposite of some late surge... I'm going to go ahead and stick with numbers, rather than your dumbass opinion.

Step your game up. Read in a little more. You aren't ready for this.
 

MalikReloaded

All Star
Joined
Sep 30, 2015
Messages
2,449
Reputation
160
Daps
10,747
Reppin
The 215
I'm going to stop you right there --

Because my point is exactly this: there is not generic "prime" that can be applied to every athlete - for the reasons I described. That is why LeBron's current season doesn't necessarily qualify for his prime. Your prime is determined by the performances you give over the course of your career.

If Lebron suddenly started shooting 58% from 3 over the next three seasons, averaging 40 a game -- then, when he retires... I'd consider that a part of his prime. But given the fact that he's less athletic than he was 5 years ago, and that his current trajectory is pointing to exactly the opposite of some late surge... I'm going to go ahead and stick with numbers, rather than your dumbass opinion.

Step your game up. Read in a little more. You aren't ready for this.

Nikka your point is retarded and wrong. Lebron was in his prime from 2009ish to 2014ish. He was the best basketball player on Earth while he was in a Miami uniform, which coincides with the typical age for a player's prime. Lebron was averaging 26 points on almost 60% shooting. Fukk are you talking about :dahell: Nothing in his old Cleveland days top that you dumb ass :dahell: THAT was his prime. And he was 26-29 then.
 

I.V.

Keep this Fire
Supporter
Joined
May 7, 2012
Messages
7,056
Reputation
2,220
Daps
17,747
Nikka your point is retarded and wrong. Lebron was in his prime from 2009ish to 2014ish. He was the best basketball player on Earth while he was in a Miami uniform, which coincides with the typical age for a player's prime. Lebron was averaging 26 points on almost 60% shooting. Fukk are you talking about :dahell: Nothing in his old Cleveland days top that you dumb ass :dahell: THAT was his prime. And he was 26-29 then.


I'm not arguing AGAINST his Miami days you simple fukk.

I'm arguing against including his most recent seasons as a part of his prime. THAT was my original point... you should NOT be using his last two seasons as a part of his prime, and EXCLUDING seasons where he was getting 30/8/8 - it was an inappropriately stacked set of statistics, used in order to make Bird look better.

I don't even dislike Larry Bird, he's an all time great. But they were using a shytty set of stats for LeBron to prove a point.


This is what happens when you don't fukking READ.

So we have established that
1) You don't understand what a physical peak is for pro athletes
and
2) You don't even read the posts you're arguing with.


Go away. Study up. Work out. Come back stronger.
 

MalikReloaded

All Star
Joined
Sep 30, 2015
Messages
2,449
Reputation
160
Daps
10,747
Reppin
The 215
Shut up you dumb fukk.

You said he was in his prime when he was 22 years old. I can quote you if you want. Nobody agrees with you. You lucky this thread is dead or else you'd sound real stupid right now to a lot of people.
 

Un-AmericanDreamer

Simp City
Joined
Jun 8, 2012
Messages
9,740
Reputation
1,313
Daps
30,393
Larry-Bird-Michael-Jordan-and-Magic-Johnson.jpg
 
Top