I think you're greatly exaggerating Eminem's history of making songs with thought provoking content. Staying on topic and having substance are two different things. I used to be a massive Eminem fan, but he doesn't have enough songs in his resume where to me his skills are put to great use like "Stan". I think the criticism that he's corny is fair with years of proof to back it up.
I don't agree that Eminem can rap better than everyone else either. I consider emcees like Nas, Andre 3000, Lupe Fiasco, Black Thought, etc to be superior. If you want an example of what I consider to be superior rapping, listen to Andre 3000's verse on "16", or all 3 verses of Lupe's "Failure" as examples.
I agree with your views on Jay-Z for the record. His content is very shallow and materialistic - especially as of late. Gets boring fast.
Firstly, I think Ab-Soul is a really talented emcee who puts a lot of thought into his rhymes. I don't think comparing him to Eminem is blasphemous at all.
Recovery over Food & Liquor II? I'd say only a hardcore stan would have that point of view, but then again, you would say the same to me wouldn't you? So no point in talking about that
Lasers was a disappointment, yes, but let's not act like it was devoid of good songs. What song on Recovery is really fukking with the lyrical content of this?
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=WWGLYEBYmyI
At least u gotta admit the only ppl u can put in the conversation is the absolute elite
C'mon breh, and that's Lupe at his creative lowpoint. That's his light
shyt.
Views on delivery and whatnot are subjective. I personally think his delivery is fine, and that Eminem's is absolutely horrible as of recent. I stick to the rhymes and the content of the words, and to me Eminem is nowhere near the level of emcee that Lupe is, and it really isn't close.
While Eminem's rhyming techniques and flow are impeccable and his talent is undeniable, the depth and thought put into the words pale in comparison to many, many, many rappers. I'm also not a fan of shock rapping in the least, so not having substance in the themes of your songs is a huge minus. The only thing talking about raping people and killing gays does for me is induce intense eye rolls. shyt's whack. You're never going to convince me that what Eminem does is more impressive than what an Andre 3000, Lupe, or Nas does.