Whips-n-Chains
Chi
I love Pun, but cmon...
Biggie gave Pun the lane, there's no Pun w/o Big giving him the whole Mafioso, crime boss, fat playa lane. Not to mention Ready to Die had about 100x the impact that Capital Punisment had...
Billboard and Vibe Magazine Top 50 Rappers of all time! #1 Jay-z #2 Kendrick #3 Nas
- Thread starter RoseWooD
- Start date
Biggie gave Pun the lane, there's no Pun w/o Big giving him the whole Mafioso, crime boss, fat playa lane. Not to mention Ready to Die had about 100x the impact that Capital Punisment had...
Whips-n-Chains
Chi
I can't be the only one that doesn't give 2 fukks about Missy Elliot...idk how she's always ranked on these lists...same with Kim and Nicki...I guess Nicki charted and Kim laid the groundwork for female rappers (who really gaf?), but their work is all trash.
Im not saying she shouldn't be on the list nor am I saying she shouldn't be rated where shes at based on how they are doing this. Im just saying clearly they are weighting certain factors more then others. Missy wouldn't be in my top 100 personally cause she wasn't anywhere close to a good rapper. The sales and impact are undeniable though. If weighing is equally it would be tough to be top 20 when the lyrics department is so lacking.
Sock it to me was the ish though
threattonature
Veteran
20 years in the game is a Jay or Nas or LL or Wayne who were still charting 20 years deep into their career. nikkas releasing albums to silence don't count. The closest you named to 20 years of relevance was Rae after OBCL2 got a decent amount of acclaim.Not in the top 10, but a top 50 list without names like Prodigy, GZA, Raekwon, etc. is pretty wild...Especially considering each have classic material + 20+ years in the game. Ludacris? cmon now
dora_da_destroyer
Master Baker
kinda how i feel about your rants about wu tang members outside of ghost...them dudes had a hot solo in the 90's, they aint impact the game beyond that.
Yeah they’re definitely trolling. Switch Wayne with Eminem.
Whips-n-Chains
Chi
Fair...I'll agree Wu's influence is more limited to the underground, and east coast, and outside of artists like Alchemist, Griselda, etc. is largely lost in today's Hip-Pop scene.
As a group the impact was obviously huge, bringing the east coast back into the picture, not doing it with any poppy or west coast sounding beats (a la Juicy)
While he didn't invent Mafioso Rap, Raekwon popularized it and set a huge trend with OB4CL, still in affect today (Drake "Mob Ties," et al)...as well as the whole 'cinematic'/crime flick approach to an album, dudes having alter-ego crime boss names.
RZA was probably the most influential producer in rap in the 90s, not named Dr. Dre, and he influenced huge acts today (Kanye).
My statement wasn't meant to single out female emcees, either. I think Lauryn Hill is underrated as an emcee, she also paved the way for female emcees, probably moreso than anyone else, she could actually spit, wrote her own ish, and did it w/o having to resort to oversexualization like Kim.
Maybe I'm misremembering, but I don't ever recall Missy having a huge impact in the 90s or early 2000s when she was poppin...I'll happily admit to being wrong if there's something I'm leaving out. At the time of release, I don't remember any of her projects having hype, selling crazy, or being impactful.
dora_da_destroyer
Master Baker
that's wild then because missy's albums and songs were everywhere and she was on a huge producing and writing run (tho for r&b)
Whips-n-Chains
Chi
I'll have to revisit some, I'm not being facetious, just having a hard time remembering her run in the early 2000s song for song outside of the obvious "Work It" and "Get Ur Freak On"
I was probably too harsh on Missy, and limiting her impact by viewing it through my personal lense. I appreciate you reminding me of her producting run and R&B too.
Unpopular opinion, but I don't look back as fondly on the early 2000s like many coli posters do...I think there's a lot of overrated albums that were good, great, classic (for the time) but not timeless...Stankonia, Stillmatic, The Blueprint, Lord Willin', GRODT, all the eminem stuff. I won't deny their impact tho.
I enjoy the blueprint, and stankonia is cool..but I'll take RD and ATLiens/Aquemini/Southernplayalistic... any day.
Last edited:
Im not saying she shouldn't be on the list nor am I saying she shouldn't be rated where shes at based on how they are doing this. Im just saying clearly they are weighting certain factors more then others. Missy wouldn't be in my top 100 personally cause she wasn't anywhere close to a good rapper. The sales and impact are undeniable though. If weighing is equally it would be tough to be top 20 when the lyrics department is so lacking.
Sock it to me was the ish though
Lyrics is 1/5 of the criteria though, so I don't know how you're forming your conclusion. An artist could still be trash rapper with good lyrics because they lack flow, delivery, and mic presence or simply can't put together a dope song.
Also how in the hell is Gucci Mane on this list and not Game?
Whips-n-Chains
Chi
He's not a true MC, but no one can deny his impact...doesn't he have more #1 hits than elvis and the beatles?
I'd like to see a list that doesn't factor in commercial success, and focuses on the quality of work...when commercial hits are taken into account you get whacked out lists with drake being a better MC than Q-Tip and Black Thought, and people like Raekwon and Prodigy not even making the top 50...
Best MC and most popular/most successful MC are different lists. Nicki Manaj & Drake are pop artists, not MCs
If you base it just on quality of music, you will get a list that makes no sense whatsoever because it will come down to personal tastes. No list is ever going to get it right.
Blaze made a list in the 90's and Prodigy wasn't on that one either. I don't even think commercial success was a factor because it Pos from De La Soul and Cee Lo from Goodie Mob on it.
None of these lists are going to be to your liking unless you make your own.
Last edited:
