Brehs,why isnt Kurt Warner mentioned when talking top QB's?

JLR Steez

Pro
Joined
Dec 22, 2014
Messages
640
Reputation
110
Daps
1,090
Reppin
RI
Faulk said they knew plays they never ran in the season and only practiced in their walkthrough


I understand, I'm saying its not a stretch to say beli and crennel were well prepared and made good in game adjustments to certain formations, packages etc. To keep it real tho, Kurt Warner tore it up in 09, I thought they had it that year.
 

MikelArteta

Moderator
Staff member
Supporter
Joined
Apr 30, 2012
Messages
262,895
Reputation
34,845
Daps
804,026
Reppin
Goatganda the pearl of Africa
When he was on he was one of the best qbs to ever play the game

Dude literally came from nowhere and had one of the best NFL seasons ever

the answer to the question in the thread title is because hes not a top qb

he wasnt consistent enough

he had like 5 good years

IMO i think its a joke that hes even a finalist for the HOF in his first year on the ballot

1st ballot HOFers are suppose to be the all time greats like Ray Lewis/Brady/Manning/Ed Reed/etc and Kurt is not in that group
 

STAN JONES

Fire John Harbaugh
Joined
May 1, 2012
Messages
30,145
Reputation
5,679
Daps
66,818
Reppin
Baltimore
When he was on he was one of the best qbs to ever play the game

Dude literally came from nowhere and had one of the best NFL seasons ever
true

he had 2 all time great seasons but thats not enough to be a 1st ballot guy IMO

if you have never been in the discussion for the best to play your position how can you be a first ballot HOFer?

not saying he shouldnt go into the Hall,just saying hes not a 1st ballot HOFer

when i think of 1st ballot HOFers its Deion,Barry,Emmitt.Montana,Brady,Manning,Ray,Ed,Sapp,Reggie White etc

hes not in the same league as those guys...not even close IMO
 

JLova

Veteran
Supporter
Joined
May 6, 2012
Messages
60,022
Reputation
4,632
Daps
182,331
Peyton is the better QB but u cant deny the fact he been blessed with talent around him. Im sure if he was throwing to scrubs he wouldn't have as good of numbers breh. U gotta give credit where credit is due to Wayne and Marv

Warner was blessed with some of the best talent any QB could ask for. The only time he didn't have that, he was in New York and was terrible.

Kurt is a HOFer but folk going overboard now.

Only reason I put him in the HOF is 3 trips to the SB and when he was on, he had some of the greatest seasons ever.
 

Leonard Washington

Superstar
Joined
May 2, 2012
Messages
11,181
Reputation
2,008
Daps
36,853
Reppin
A little town called none ya got damn bidness
I :salute:his rags to riches story. That magical season with the Rams took everybody by storm. When healthy the guy flatout balled. He had some down years and bounced back and made Zona a contender. The guy put in work and deserves to be in Canton. I think he is a tier 2-3 on the Goat status which is nothing to sneeze at
 

Cladyclad

Veteran
Supporter
Joined
Jun 3, 2012
Messages
48,490
Reputation
5,540
Daps
123,666
Reppin
Detroit Lions, Michigan Wolverines & LWO
:mindblown: how da fuc is he a finalist?

so does that mean Mcnabb getting in too? because if u are a 1st ballot finalist u getting in more than likely. If Warner gets in before that WR who went to Syracuse. im gon be heated!!
 
Top