O.iatlhawksfan
Devoted Joel Embiid hater
What a wild post lol
Cam Explains Why He Left Jalen Hurts Off His Top 10 QBs List
- Thread starter Big Boss
- Start date
IIVI
Superstar
I like the fact Bryce has bounced back and in non-ideal conditions. It was really bad, but that’s the worst it’ll most likely get. Dude learned and was thriving in the same bad conditions got really comfortable and relaxed the 2nd half of the NFL season.
I’m always skeptical of early incredible seasons because unless conditions are right (Mahomes with Andy Reid) it usually isn’t sustainable.
I additionally don’t think Baker is better than Jalen.
We’ll see I guess.
etrofllenrod504
Superstar
No Barkley in the 1st Super Bowl they lost and they were only in that game because of Jalen cause Patty was chewing them up. What was the excuse then? Cause he out played Pat. Talks about who he has around him but, I bet he won’t use the same argument for Burrow lol Burrow been throwing to elite wideouts since LSU nobody says shyt.
Now it’s knock a Jalen cause he has talent around him. We saw what Philly offense looked like those few games without Jalen(they weren’t good).
Sad it’s coming from Cam cause Jalen basically of the mold play style wise, except being a more efficient passer lol.
Now it’s knock a Jalen cause he has talent around him. We saw what Philly offense looked like those few games without Jalen(they weren’t good).
Sad it’s coming from Cam cause Jalen basically of the mold play style wise, except being a more efficient passer lol.
etrofllenrod504
Superstar
This is such a ridiculous thing to say when they done won the Super Bowl and he was mvp lol
RennisDeynolds
I am untethered and my rage knows no bounds!
Don't matter what anybody thinks. He got that chip
Mahomes under the two QB's who can't beat him
Why isn't he downgrading Burrow for having Chase and Higgins yet still losing?
He should actually bump Burrow ahead of Mahomes, Burrow can beat him.
---
Top 10 lists are trash and there's barely 10 NFL QBs you'd actually want.
You don't have to wonder, just have to stop grading QBs on ring count, which as you point out here...is a team level accomplishment.
VegetasHairline
Veteran
I don't care how good his arm talent is, I'll gladly take Jalen Hurts over Justin Herbert.
and he's waaaaaaaay better than Tua
Hurts is top 10 by default. He's a champion, he wins way more than he loses, and he makes winning plays more often than not. However, he isn't as statistically productive as many of his peers, particularly when it comes to throwing the ball, and he lacks the arm talent of some of his peers. Anyone who watches the game can see that.
Multiple things can be true: He generally plays his best when it matters and should be more consistently productive statistically, given his supporting cast. Oh well. It depends on what you want from your QB, and he does what's asked. I think there are a few QBs who could replicate what Hurts does in the Philadelphia offense, and that the Eagles can win without him. But it won't look quite the same.
All that said, the first order of business is that people must accept that the QB's job, above all else, is to manage the game and do what is required to win. At the very least, the QB has to avoid causing a loss. Being a game manager is not a bad thing, and there are way more of them than there are "elite QBs" or "gamechangers."
Multiple things can be true: He generally plays his best when it matters and should be more consistently productive statistically, given his supporting cast. Oh well. It depends on what you want from your QB, and he does what's asked. I think there are a few QBs who could replicate what Hurts does in the Philadelphia offense, and that the Eagles can win without him. But it won't look quite the same.
All that said, the first order of business is that people must accept that the QB's job, above all else, is to manage the game and do what is required to win. At the very least, the QB has to avoid causing a loss. Being a game manager is not a bad thing, and there are way more of them than there are "elite QBs" or "gamechangers."
Box Factory
hater
I'm insanely biased, but he's top 5 at worst.
Lamar and Allen are the only guys that unless you're some sort of football big brain, you can 100% tell me are better than Jalen
Lamar and Allen are the only guys that unless you're some sort of football big brain, you can 100% tell me are better than Jalen
feelosofer
#ninergang
In a weird way as a 49er fan this is similar to the Brock Purdy argument but even less fair. Jalen is more than what he does on the field. First off the tush push doesn't work as well as it does without Hurts incredible lower body strength. He performs at key moments in the game and I would even argue his maturity works as a counter balance to Nick Siriani's brashness. In every big game he has made several key plays to move the game forward. Will he ever be the QB that throws for 4500 yards and 40 TDs, probably not but he is more integral to what the Eagles run than people realize. Just speaking to last year he was absolutely a top QB and he should be where CJ Stroud is at minimum.
Thought this was gonna be Cam’ron 
I thought I was going to have more QB's where I didn't have to think twice about taking over him, but my list for that is shorter than I thought.
Mahomes
Lamar
Allen
Burrow
There are probably some other QB's I'd take over him just based on the eye test, but those are the only ones where I instantly say "no" to taking him over.
-Then you have players like Dak, Goff, Mayfield, and Stafford that have been around for a long time. I can see arguments for them, but I can also see how people aren't huge on then.
-You then have some of the younger QB's such as Herbert, Love, Daniels, Stroud, and Lawrence. Again, I may take some of them over Hurts, but we've seen QB's like Stroud take a step back after their rookie season. We'll see if the same happens with Jayden.
I did everything I could not to put Drake Maye on here, although he will be on every top ten list after this year.
Mahomes
Lamar
Allen
Burrow
There are probably some other QB's I'd take over him just based on the eye test, but those are the only ones where I instantly say "no" to taking him over.
-Then you have players like Dak, Goff, Mayfield, and Stafford that have been around for a long time. I can see arguments for them, but I can also see how people aren't huge on then.
-You then have some of the younger QB's such as Herbert, Love, Daniels, Stroud, and Lawrence. Again, I may take some of them over Hurts, but we've seen QB's like Stroud take a step back after their rookie season. We'll see if the same happens with Jayden.
I did everything I could not to put Drake Maye on here, although he will be on every top ten list after this year.