Black Excellence
All Star
I agree with some of those nitpicks I will say tho that doesn’t necessarily make it a bad film because you disagree with the creative direction. Objectively the only thing bad wasThis film was all over the place. Felt like a bunch of interesting ideas strung together. The world building here is weak and raises more questions than it answers. I really enjoyed the first hour, great tension and great camera work. But then it got weird and I just didn’t buy many of the decisions that the characters made, which took me out of the movie. I also did not like the stylistic direction Boyle took with the kills and inter mixing of old images and film within new scenes. Again those things took me out of the movie because they felt too heavy handed. And the last two minutes were ridiculous, but it did make me laugh so I guess that’s something. Really disappointed though overall. 5/10
the sudden & convenient inclusion of the soldiers, the tonal shift of the ending and the CGI in the water