Come help me settle an argument.. Reggie Miller VS Brandon Roy

[Donald Trumps Twitter]

Might as well ask Jeremy Lins first 10 days with the Knicks or Magic Johnsons first 10 day with the Lakers

 

[ISO]

Brandon Roy is so overrated to the point where I hate him. Smh

nikkas swear this kid was a future hof.. No..

He could have been

 

[EducatedBrothaFromTheBank]

It's hard to do this comparison because we never got to see Roy in his prime, look at the kind of numbers Harden & Westbrook are putting up at 27 and 28, and the last time we saw Roy at his best he was only 25.

Roy was in a much tougher era in the West, the talent pool in the NBA right now is the worst it's ever been.. you got average nikkas like Isaiah Thomas averaging 29ppg

 

[Gil Scott-Heroin]

Roy was in a much tougher era in the West, the talent pool in the NBA right now is the worst it's ever been.. you got average nikkas like Isaiah Thomas averaging 29ppg

 

[stepbackj34spud]

He could have been

You don't know what his production would've been like over the next few years. Deron Williams was on pace to be a hall of fame PG and he fell off once he got his bread. I hate when nikkas say that. Part of being a hall of fame player is having longevity.

 

[stepbackj34spud]

Roy was in a much tougher era in the West, the talent pool in the NBA right now is the worst it's ever been.. you got average nikkas like Isaiah Thomas averaging 29ppg

IT is a legit scoring threat threat. It has nothing to do with the talent pool in the league.

 

[ALonelyDad]

Reggie Miller but damn I wish we got to see Roy finish his career. He was cold

 

[KRiLL (+)]

i was a Brandon Roy stan, so yea...

 

[Regular_P]

I can't believe the vote is this lopsided. I like Reggie, but if we're discounting injuries and everything else, Roy at his best was better than him.

 

[Hammer]

this is one of the worst threads i have ever seen in my life

a hall of famer or brandon roy?

is this a fukking joke?

@904 fukk you retard

 

[Gil Scott-Heroin]

I can't believe the vote is this lopsided. I like Reggie, but if we're discounting injuries and everything else, Roy at his best was better than him.

It shouldn't be surprising at all - Reggie at his best anchored some of the league's best offenses throughout the regular season and postseason (one of the better playoff performers of his era), while being ultra efficient with a high volume scoring load, all without being ball-dominant. Whereas Roy's "best" is what he basically did at age 24. Did he have a better overall skillset than Reggie? Sure. But in terms of impact over a generous period? Nah.

 

[ghostwriterx]

Roy was in a much tougher era in the West, the talent pool in the NBA right now is the worst it's ever been.. you got average nikkas like Isaiah Thomas averaging 29ppg

 

[I AM WARHOL]

 

[Roland Coltrane]

I can't believe the vote is this lopsided. I like Reggie, but if we're discounting injuries and everything else, Roy at his best was better than him.

no he wasn't, especially if you take the playoffs into account
Reggie Miller vs. Brandon Roy Comparison

Reggie's name rings bells and he's a legend for a reason

if your squad was in a close game with the Pacers the fear of God was in you just by virtue of the fact that Reggie was on the floor


Reggie TERRORIZED opposing teams and fanbases

 

[AlbertPullhoez]

Brandon was a better all around player except 3 point shooting

Reggie just got better knees