Come help me settle an argument.. Reggie Miller VS Brandon Roy

[Regular_P]

It shouldn't be surprising at all - Reggie at his best anchored some of the league's best offenses throughout the regular season and postseason (one of the better playoff performers of his era), while being ultra efficient with a high volume scoring load, all without being ball-dominant. Whereas Roy's "best" is what he basically did at age 24. Did he have a better overall skillset than Reggie? Sure. But in terms of impact over a generous period? Nah.

no he wasn't, especially if you take the playoffs into account
Reggie Miller vs. Brandon Roy Comparison

Reggie's name rings bells and he's a legend for a reason

if your squad was in a close game with the Pacers the fear of God was in you just by virtue of the fact that Reggie was on the floor


Reggie TERRORIZED opposing teams and fanbases

This argument isn't taking longevity and injuries into consideration though; strictly each player at their best. 2008-09 Brandon Roy was better than any version of Reggie Miller.

 

[Roland Coltrane]

This argument isn't taking longevity and injuries into consideration though; strictly each player at their best. 2008-09 Brandon Roy was better than any version of Reggie Miller.

nah








but out of curiosity how did you come to this conclusion

 

[Gil Scott-Heroin]

This argument isn't taking longevity and injuries into consideration though; strictly each player at their best. 2008-09 Brandon Roy was better than any version of Reggie Miller.

And that's how I'm comparing them. We never got to see Roy at his best over a generous period that would warrant ranking him ahead of Reggie who was a more dominant offensive player - if only marginally (even despite not having a better overall skillset). Especially given the fact he was still only 24 and didn't have the advantage of growing into his game and fine-tuning it like Reggie did in his late-20s.

 

[daboywonder2002]

Clutch. Plays without the ball. Durability. Reggie

 

[Big Boss]

Reggie

 

[904]

this is one of the worst threads i have ever seen in my life

a hall of famer or brandon roy?

is this a fukking joke?

@904 fukk you retard

I'm not with the disrespectful shyt bruh.. You wouldn't talk to me like this in person so keep this bullshyt to yaself

 

[Sonny Corinthos]

Having seen what Reggie did to the Knicks live and the goat level moment of Brandon Roy on no knees against the Mavs I can say we were robbed as ball fans that Roy was never healthy.

But clearly Reggie Miller had the better career and most likely would of had Roy got a healthy career as well.

Reggie Miller is easily a top 5 shooter of all time and was probably the most clutch shooter I've ever witnessed.

Brandon Roy was great but he was never gonna be a better sg than Reggie

 

[Hammer]

I'm not with the disrespectful shyt bruh.. You wouldn't talk to me like this in person so keep this bullshyt to yaself

shut the fukk up

 

[General Mills]

Got damn Brandon was that nikka before the injuries.

One year he saved my fantasy basketball team damn near dolo.

 

[malbaker86]

Reggie.

 

[El Coupeacabra]

Who the fukk is Brandon Roy?

Roy was a bad motherfukker.

And this was AFTER his knee got bad. Against the Mavs team that took down the Heat.

 

[AJtheOne]

Reggie played like 20 years

Roy played like only 5 years

this is kinda unfair.

Roy vs Penny or Roy vs Grant Hill would probably be a better match up. Since those guys primes were cut short by injury.

 

[Rigby.]

Brandon Roy is my favorite what if player, that's all I have to add to this conversation

 

[Rigby.]

Roy was a bad motherfukker.

And this was AFTER his knee got bad. Against the Mavs team that took down the Heat.

Why did God take this man away from us the generation between LeBron fans and Curry fans would've actually had somebody to respect instead of having to dikkride Curry just because he's what's hot
A hurt Roy would still mentally break Curry

 

[904]

shut the fukk up

nikkas real tough on the internet