Listening to horror stories from an educator of 20+ years about these types of situations where the kids fukking up.....
Y'all really have no idea.

I agree with this... but lets not forget that we are dealing with children here. With that being said, non compliance from a child shouldn't have yielded corrective tactics that are reserved criminals in a precinct..
Do you think the argument can be made that the way the cop extradited from her from the class was just as disruptive as her prior behavior...?
That's exactly what happened. He tossed her across the room despite her best efforts to stay in the seat.framing the context of the situation to fit the narrative of some brute using his might to overpower someone excessively.




Before I address this, I need to say that I think you and way too many posters are taking liberties with the word "child" here.
Underage? Yes.
Minor. Of course.
"Child", though semantically accurate here, is framing the context of the situation to fit the narrative of some brute using his might to overpower someone excessively. Correct me if i'm wrong, but isn't this a teenager in a high school? Adolescents (from a clinical standpoint), are not considered "children".
To address your question though, that argument would miss the point. Once she behaves in such a manner, the only way to end any continued disruption is for her to end the behavior. Most of us I believe are in agreement that physical removal of some degree was the only solution. I would say it's not a matter of it being a bigger disruption but a continuation of the initial problem. And again, he didn't pull out a night stick and beat his rent money out of her, he didn't tase her, he didn't shoot her while she was obeying the law minding her business. The only thing i'm critical of concerning his removal is that if the option for another officer or school staff existed to assist him, than that should have been used, because that lessens the chance of injury to everyone.
He doesn't need to have his own kids to understand that, dude's just incompetent in his job. I wouldn't want this dude anywhere near children.The cop got into a fight with her. Which is what she wanted. She dared them to fight. They took the invitation.
She wasn't listening because she thought their "discipline" was unreasonable.
They did nothing but come in and give her some real unreasonable discipline.
And now she's all over the news with people siding with her. She got what she wanted and all she was taught was to meet adversity with violence
No. Go read any psychological study on children's behavior. Fighting there tantrums with violence of your own only reinforces the behavior.
Do you have kids?
I'll google it for you
Cop broke the first rule and only reinforced the behavior. I thought you were an expert on this
What actions required her to be removed right at that moment?
What?!?
Listening to horror stories from an educator of 20+ years about these types of situations where the kids fukking up.....
Y'all really have no idea.
I told you the truth from my own experience first. You pivoted from the truth so I gathered an expert opinion to back up my own.What?!?
Look, you're actually one of the very few posters in this thread capable of engaging in this debate with some maturity apparently, so I'm not just trying to sh*t on you and derail the thread again, but did you seriously just google a response for a stock clinical diagnosis, (after announcing that you googled it no less), and expect that to be taken as something of merit??
Whatever you googled isn't even applicable here, it's speaking on children and parenting, not adolescents and non-family authority figures (who happens to be a police officer, not the school counselor).
What did she do that required she be removed from the class?What warranted her being removed from the class is her behavior becoming problematic in fostering a proper learning environment. The TEACHER decides that, because she (or he) is the one that has to teach the class. It wasn't the cop that made that decision, and it damn sure should never be one of the students.
