Did Eminem really Kill Jay-Z on "Renegade" or was that overstated?

[nomas]

Jay started it by claiming that Horse had the better verse on oochie wally.
nas took jay's insult and flipped it and made a more memorable/funny line out of it
and 'murdered you on your own shyt' was born!!

This is true.

 

[mr.africa]

so you admit it was nas, thank you.

no
jay had the idea,but not the attractive packaging
like i said jay started it.
nas' version was just more memorable!!

 

[Marciano]

I thought Em just came with more emotion, although his verses were tough. Jay was his usual self, but lyrically it was on point. The way he was painting pictures with "I had to hustle, back to the wall, ashy knuckles/Pockets filled with a lot of lint, not a cent" - a lot of us can relate that. Matter fact, most of what Jay was saying, folks from the hood can relate to. Em was just going straight at this critics. I say it was an equal showing from great emcees.

 

[Suicide King]

Jay is getting slaughtered in the voting.

 

[Billy Ocean]

I'm not a fan of whiteboy and he's definitely, without question the most overrated MC ever, but when I hear this...

"Since I'm in the position to talk to these kids and they listen..."



Jay came with some run of the mill Jay sh!t. He got murdered.

 

[Billy Ocean]

Jay is getting slaughtered in the voting.

Rightfully so.

 

[Suicide King]

I'm not a fan of whiteboy and he's definitely, without question the most overrated MC ever, but when i hear this...

"Since I'm in the position to talk to these kids and they listen..."



Jay came with some run of the mill Jay sh!t. He got murdered.

Also, when he said, "You fukking do-gooders - too bad you couldn't DO-GOOD at marriage!"

This line got me, it captured the phoniness of American culture, right wing conservatives, white culture, those judgmental black religious folks, etc....

 

[General Mills]

Jay started it by claiming that Horse had the better verse on oochie wally.
nas took jay's insult and flipped it and made a more memorable/funny line out of it
and 'murdered you on your own shyt' was born!!

Came in here to say this also.

 

[Billy Ocean]

Also, when he said, "You fukking do-gooders - too bad you couldn't DO-GOOD at marriage!"

This line got me, it captured the phoniness of American culture, right wing conservatives, white culture, those judgmental black religious folks, etc....

Yea, Em really flexed his lyrical muscle on that track something serious. And everyone I was around at that time said that he got Jay a lot on that track. Before Ether.

 

[The Ruler 09]

I preferred Jay's verses.

 

[Bickin Back Being Bool]

no
jay had the idea,but not the attractive packaging
like i said jay started it.
nas' version was just more memorable!!

if people are saying "so n so murdered on your own sh!t" its nas b, we all remember the battle and who said what first

stop caping

 

[BlackMajik]

And if u need another example of Jay getting outshined (Not on his own song tho but u get the point)




Big Boi & Killer Mike murdered Flip Flop Rock

 

[DopeMan]

I don't know where the fvck you from, but EVERYBODY was talking about how Em murdered Jay on that track where I'm from.

Jay got ate something delicious on Renegade. It is what it is. Jay stans move on.

Your the type of Nas dikrider I was referring to in my post so I expect you to say shyt like that

 

[Axum Ezana]

em got the first verse...jay got the second. em flowed better the whole track.

em edged him out....but he definitely did NOT OVERKILL HIM like they make it out to be.

 

[Billy Ocean]

Your the type of Nas dikrider I was referring to in my post so I expect you to say shyt like that

You the type of camel hump jockey that would get furious for me telling it like it is, so I expected a response like that