Donovan McNabb vs Michael Vick

[CourtesyFlush]

Who was the better black QB and why?

 

[FabTrey]

vick has higher peak, but you go with mcnabb for durability and consistency.

 

[premier58]

vick has higher peak, but you go with mcnabb for durability and consistency.

How does Vick have a higher peak? Please explain..McNabb was always better than Vick.

 

[AlbertPullhoez]

McNabb got this. Imagine if he didn't spend majority of his Philly days playing with garbage ass receivers

 

[Da King]

McNabb gave up and quit on the biggest stage, cost TO a ring and Super Bowl MVP

 

[premier58]

McNabb got this. Imagine if he didn't spend majority of his Philly days playing with garbage ass receivers

Not even close. Vick only made the playoffs 3 times as a starter. Thats it..

 

[GR13]

Mc5 for me obviously he's not as athletically gifted as Vick but Donovan is still a very athletically gifted in his on right and even though McNabb has flaws in his game he is still a
more skilled/polished QB then Vick

people forget how fast and how elusive a runner young Donovan was








amazing pocket escapability and great instinctual play making ability to find/locate receiver on the run/scramble

 

[Voice of Reason]

Mc5 for me obviously he's not as athletically gifted as Vick but Donovan is still a very athletically gifted in his on right and even though McNabb has flaws in his game he is still a
more skilled/polished QB then Vick

people forget how fast and how elusive a runner young Donovan was





amazing pocket escapability and great instinctual play making ability to find/locate receiver on the run/scramble

Now put up some Vick videos

 

[MegaTronBomb!]

McNabb is the best black QB ever.

If we really being honest, Vick isn't even a top 5 black QB.

 

[010101]

mcnabb was vick big.homie

vick was the goat athlete to ever play qb doe

but shout out to mcnabb

*

 

[010101]

Now put up some Vick videos

this alone is enough



it'll never be done again

*

 

[staticshock]

 

[T’Challa’s Heir]

McNabb and it’s not even close.

 

[broller]

Mc5 for me obviously he's not as athletically gifted as Vick but Donovan is still a very athletically gifted in his on right and even though McNabb has flaws in his game he is still a
more skilled/polished QB then Vick

people forget how fast and how elusive a runner young Donovan was





amazing pocket escapability and great instinctual play making ability to find/locate receiver on the run/scramble

I remember this play on MNF

 

[broller]

McNabb was the better passer and quarterback and was better for much longer.

In my mind, Vick had two good years (2002 and 2010). His 2010 was excellent though. I wish Vick had studied more, as well as played in this era where coaches are more open to building around talent rather than fitting talent around their rigid scheme. Maybe we'll see what Vick could have been with Lamar in Baltimore