Elway was overrated right?

[iPod Raheem 2.0]

Oh and Favre>Elway

Farve got multiple seasons that shyt on Elways best.

Plus he was better in that Super Bowl

 

[FreedS[ohh]lave]

Look at his "weapons" till late in his career not too good

he was bascially Farve[guslinger who took chances] with a a shyt cast around him till 97

Too look at just stats in a game like football is beyond dumb theyres way too many variables in the game

People wil tell you who played the game or watched it that Archie Manning was one of the best qb's they played against or saw but his numbers were bad because of the team he played on

 

[Da_Eggman]

never was in the same league as Marino

 

[iPod Raheem 2.0]

Look at his "weapons" till late in his career not too good

he was bascially Farve[guslinger who took chances] with a a shyt cast around him till 97

Too look at just stats in a game like football is beyond dumb theyres way too many variables in the game

People wil tell you who played the game or watched it that Archie Manning was one of the best qb's they played against or saw but his numbers were bad because of the team he played on

This. But be clear, Shannon Sharpe was a beast.

 

[the next guy]

John Elway is basically the most overrated qb to ever play.

Comp%

A) 56.9
B) 57.9

Yards/Game

A) 219.9
B) 210.7

TD/G

A) 1.28
B) 1.17

Int/G

A) 0.96
B) 0.86

TD/Int

A) 1.32
B) 1.36

QB Rating

A) 79.9
B) 80.4

These 2 qb's are basically the same. By some metrics qb B is better than qb A. QB A is considered to be among the best qb's to ever play the game and is John Elway. QB B is Jeff George. Statistically speaking, John Elway is a more mistake prone version of George but was branded a winner because he played his entire career on strong teams.

read it and weep.

 

[NYC Rebel]

Bernie Kosar was more his peer than was Montana or Marino.

 

[iPod Raheem 2.0]

read it and weep.

Bernie Kosar was more his peer than was Montana or Marino.

It's clear now that this thread is flooded with nikkas who never saw #7 play

He passed the HOF eye test, brehs he passed the gatdamn test!

 

[mastermind]

Who said Elway wasn't a HOFer? That's not the argument. You can deserve to be in the HOF and be overrated. You letting emotions get in the way of facts.

 

[gho3st]

I know we've been over this before....and his years in the 80's I was young for but...


John Elway NFL Football Statistics - Pro-Football-Reference.com

Prior to 1993

you should judge him on how he rated against the rest of the league at that time.

 

[the next guy]

It's clear now that this thread is flooded with nikkas who never saw #7 play

He passed the HOF eye test, brehs he passed the gatdamn test!

THATS THE SAME shyt SKIP SAYS WHEN PPL BRINGS UP TEABOWS STATS.
HES A WINNER.



​

I mean come on, I provided proof that Jeff George was just as good as he was.

 

[iPod Raheem 2.0]

What about all those 4th quarter comebacks??

They should've never gave you nikkas computers

 

[mastermind]

you should judge him on how he rated against the rest of the league at that time.

Maybe YOU should do that. You would be surprised.


He was a white Donovan McNabb, the only difference is that Elway ended his career with stacked teams while Donovan was kicked to the curb.

 

[iPod Raheem 2.0]

THATS THE SAME shyt SKIP SAYS WHEN PPL BRINGS UP TEABOWS STATS.
HES A WINNER.



​

Did you just compare me to Skip in reference to my advocacy approach?

 

[Da_Eggman]

Ken Anderson > Elway

 

[mastermind]

What about all those 4th quarter comebacks??

A lot of those were his own fault.


Jake Plummer had a lot of great comebacks too, but you prolly dismiss it because its Jake Plummer.

Elway was a made for Sportscenter player