Elway was overrated right?

[NYC Rebel]

Let's see, in this thread, nikkas have compared John fukkin Elway to Bernie Kosar, Jake Plummer, Jeff George, and someone named Ken fukkin Anderson These were not fukkin compliments

And they've said that he doesn't belong in the same convo as Marino and Jim fukkin Kelly







I could you saying he's just as good, but you couldn't be reasonable

Learn your football history if you think Ken and Bernie were scrubs.

Some of you dudes have shyt for opinions.

 

[JLova]

The Elway hate is amazing. Calm down, he was a great qb but no one is on his shyt like that.

It's not hate. Horseface been shoved down our throats for years. I remember that nikka's football game sitting next to tecmo bowl and

To hear how dudes put him in their top 3 makes me sick. He should be calling Peyton "papa".

 

[NYC Rebel]

@ iPod Raheem 2.0

QB #1
86
310 out of 531 58.4% 3854 yards 17 td 10 ints

87
241 out of 389 62.0% 3033 yards 22 tds 9 ints

88 injured

89
303 out of 513 59.1% 3533 yards 18tds 14 ints

QB #2

86
280 out of 504 55.6% 3485 yards 19tds 13 ints

88
274 out of 496 55.2% 3309 yards 17 tds 19 ints

89

223 out of 416 53.6% 3051 yards 18 tds 18 ints


Whose numbers are better?

 

[yseJ]

yall are underestimating montanas arm and overestimating rodgers' arm.
montana's passes on the run were just as good, if not better

montana could make 50-60 yard passes in the air just as well

 

[NYC Rebel]

yall are underestimating montanas arm and overestimating rodgers' arm.
montana's passes on the run were just as good, if not better

montana could make 50-60 yard passes in the air just as well

Dog



do




not




go




there!!!

Montana didn't have anywhere NEAR the arm strength and velocity of A-Rod.

Stop it!!!

I watched Joe since he was scrambling Joe and his career almost ended with a back injury my dude. It was always known that he didn't have a strong arm.

Come on man. Lets chill with that.

 

[the next guy]

Let's see, in this thread, nikkas have compared John fukkin Elway to Bernie Kosar, Jake Plummer, Jeff George, and someone named Ken fukkin Anderson These were not fukkin compliments

And they've said that he doesn't belong in the same convo as Marino and Jim fukkin Kelly







I could see you saying he's just as good, but you couldn't be reasonable

I posted proof that Jeff George was just as good as he was though. This is what @mastermind was talking about. What exactly is Elway better than George at? Than Marino at? The stats are here in this thread.

 

[JLova]

yall are underestimating montanas arm and overestimating rodgers' arm.
montana's passes on the run were just as good, if not better

montana could make 50-60 yard passes in the air just as well

Joe's arm was weak, breh. Not Pennington weak, but it was weak.

 

[yseJ]

at 0:50
that pass travels from own 35 to nearly 15 yard line...thats an almost 50 yard pass FULLY ON THE RUN

montanas arm was fine for all NFL throws

 

[NYC Rebel]

Montana Magic - Part 2 of 3 - YouTube

at 0:50
that pass travels from own 35 to nearly 15 yard line...thats an almost 50 yard pass FULLY ON THE RUN

montanas arm was fine for all NFL throws

Bullshyt.

I can show a Harold Miner youtube film and it would prove that he could make "all the shots."

Montana did not have a strong arm. That was a known fact and known to all 49ers fans. He could NOT make all the throws.

 

[holidayinn21]

yall are underestimating montanas arm and overestimating rodgers' arm.
montana's passes on the run were just as good, if not better

montana could make 50-60 yard passes in the air just as well

the fukk?

 

[mastermind]

Learn your football history if you think Ken and Bernie were scrubs.

Some of you dudes have shyt for opinions.

and he the one who is arguing FOR Elway and admonishing everyone for saying he was overrated as if he watched him in his prime.

yall are underestimating montanas arm and overestimating rodgers' arm.
montana's passes on the run were just as good, if not better

montana could make 50-60 yard passes in the air just as well

no breh, no

 

[NYC Rebel]

and he the one who is arguing FOR Elway and admonishing everyone for saying he was overrated as if he watched him in his prime.

Exactly.

It's ridiculous. And for him to say "some Ken Anderson" dude as if Ken isn't a candidate for the hall of fame and should be in there says it all.

I'm still waiting for dude to tell me whose numbers are better.

 

[NYC Rebel]

This is all that separated John Elway from Bernie Kosar in the 80s

 

[yseJ]

Bullshyt.

I can show a Harold Miner youtube film and it would prove that he could make "all the shots."

Montana did not have a strong arm. That was a known fact and known to all 49ers fans. He could NOT make all the throws.

again Ive shown a proof of him physically making a ridiculously difficult throw where a pass is throw 50 yards in the air on the run.

nfl plays usually arent designed to go more than 50 yards in the air anyway.
hes had an arm to make any throws required.

rodgers has a strong arm, but not even that strong either. hes not top 5 in the nfl or anything. trust me, Ive watched him from cal days and Ive watched him pretty closely in the nfl. guys like vick cutler stafford flacco all have much much stronger arms

 

[JLova]

Montana Magic - Part 2 of 3 - YouTube

at 0:50
that pass travels from own 35 to nearly 15 yard line...thats an almost 50 yard pass FULLY ON THE RUN

montanas arm was fine for all NFL throws

brehzerp... Joe's lack of arm strength was no secret.

"Despite his performance on the field, Montana was not rated highly by most scouts. At one combine, Montana rated out as six-and-a-half overall with a six in arm strength, used to judge how hard and how far a prospect could throw the ball. By comparison, Jack Thompson of Washington State rated an eight, the highest grade among eligible quarterbacks.[11]"

Joe Montana - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia