Gary Payton vs Jason Kidd

...


  • Total voters
    116

Street Knowledge

Veteran
Supporter
Joined
May 2, 2012
Messages
27,640
Reputation
2,598
Daps
66,763
Reppin
NYC
Also Kidd sucked as as shooter, and that limited him as an overall offensive player. He shot under 40 % 9 times in his career. Even the season where people said he was "robbed" of an MVP. And he always ran terrible offensive teams, even in the nets Hey day, they won mostly because of their all time great defense(02-04)

Payton on offense>>>Kidd

And PG defense is overrated but Payton on Defense>>>>>>Kidd

I don't see an argument for Kidd here
 

PTBG

Superstar
Joined
May 13, 2012
Messages
13,852
Reputation
1,571
Daps
16,762
Reppin
Cali
lmao aye yoo the f**k happened to GP on Inside NBA? the dude was hella funny and dumb as hell on Inside NBA. The dude was a fool. I remember the "beef" he had with Chuck when he got at the Warriors during the 07 playoffs and GP was bout to bring the goons out on Chuck for talking that sh!t, bay ni**as don't play that sh!t!!! :bustback:
 
Joined
May 11, 2012
Messages
35,249
Reputation
10,171
Daps
107,585
Reppin
NULL
You keep bringing up stats... did you ever actually WATCH Payton play?


Plenty of times.



A demon at man to man D and carried himself with a cocky, overconfident swagger.


Beyond that, the rest of his game never stood out to me.



He had that rugged back to the basket game and a ugly, knuckle ball J.


It's only certain players at the PG position that you can say "disregard the stats" for.


Mostly it's the pure pg's you say that about.I've seen J Kidd dominate games without having to score a bucket.Using his D, court vision, rebounding, and overall hustle ability.


Magic is another one.



Payton was more like Russel Westbrook in terms of PG style, but not as fast or quick.Later in his career, he became a better passer, but he was never one to dominate a game with his passing abilities.


In fact, Russel right now is a better player than Payton ever was.He's balling and his team is contending for a ship.


Payton's best years came when Seattle was struggling to make the 8th seed



The proof is in the pudding with him and Kemp.They were both good players, but not great.I think people overrate them because of the dunk highlights and the swag.As somebody already said, them dudes got knocked out by a 8th seed when they were a #1.They're not built for greatness.


People underrate Detlef Schrempf & Nate Mcmillan on that '96 Sonics team.It wasn't just Payton holding MJ to under 30.

That Seattle team had some of the best team defense I've ever seen.What they did to Hakeem and the Rockets in the playoffs that year was:krs:.They were good in the regular season that year.#2 in points allowed, but they were suffering through some injuries.McMillan was banged up, but got healthy right as the playoffs started.When he came back, the D started peaking at the right time.It was beautiful.In fact, that team made me appreciate defense.They put the total fukking clamps on the Rockets.

In fact, The only team I think could top them is the '04 Pistons...in terms of team defense.

The '08 celtics were pretty good, to
 

Street Knowledge

Veteran
Supporter
Joined
May 2, 2012
Messages
27,640
Reputation
2,598
Daps
66,763
Reppin
NYC
They were great,Quite a few teams were better then the sonics D.

93' Knicks
97' Heat
01' spurs
04' spurs
04' pistons
02'/03' Nets
08' Celtics
08' Spurs

Etc
 
Joined
May 11, 2012
Messages
35,249
Reputation
10,171
Daps
107,585
Reppin
NULL
They were great,Quite a few teams were better then the sonics D.

93' Knicks
97' Heat
01' spurs
04' spurs
04' pistons
02'/03' Nets
08' Celtics
08' Spurs

Etc


I was talking since '96


The only team that I would put ahead of them is the '04 Pistons.I'll admit that Seattle can't fukk with them.Them dudes was on some borg/one collective mind shyt


But all those other teams, it's not really much of a difference.I'd put the '96 Sonics D up against any of them
 

L. Deezy

Veteran
Joined
May 25, 2012
Messages
40,976
Reputation
5,379
Daps
91,874
Payton.. thats my fav PG of all time. Well him Magic Johnson and Kenny Anderson

but Kidd is a monster but Payton was better
 
Top