The Massacre dropped in 2005 though. Act like that wasn't one of the most, if not most aniticipated album of '05. Act like "Piggybank" wasn't a big deal when it dropped. Act like he didn't have non-single album cuts heavy in the streets. That album and 50 was inescapable in 2005. When you add the Get Rich or Die Tryin' Soundtrack (which also dropped in 2005) to the equation, there's no way Jeezy was bigger than 50 in '05. "Hustler's Ambition" and "Window Shopper" were everywhere including being big in the streets.
As far as The Game, no one in G-Unit (except 50) was bigger than him in '05. The Documentary was the biggest album to come out of that crew aside from Beg For Mercy and 50's albums.