Has Durant passed Carmelo all time?

[wire28]

This is how you earned that WOAT title breh

@ any idiot who would take Melo over KD

just when you think that nikka will be de-throned, he posts some shyt like he has in this thread just to let you realize he is serious about that back to back

#WPOY2014

 

[TheGreatShowtime]

How many NCAA titles he got tho?

Spoiler

Spoiler

Corey Brewer has two NCAA rings. That means he's twice as better as Durant

 

[AVXL]

not against Melo. head to head Melo outscores him, shoots a higher percentage, and gets more wins.

and Melo woulda won the title in 2012 with Westbrook, Harden, and Ibaka.

just when you think that nikka will be de-throned, he posts some shyt like he has in this thread just to let you realize he is serious about that back to back

#WPOY2014

I'm sittin here reading this shyt in disbelief. I literally got the face reading this shyt. Melo literally does nothing better than KD yet b/c of arbitrary head to head matchups @Swagnificent would rather take Melo



Him & @track 1 will be an epic battle of horrible posting for #WPOY2014

 

[intruder]

Durant's resume at the NBA level >>> Carmelo's

I also like his game better. Carmelo is just a slower Durant but i like the fact that he's more physical than Durant. You cant go wrong with picking either, tho i'd pick Durant in most situations

 

[Victim of Racism]

I don't exactly remember each of those games, and you might be right from a fg% point of view. all i know is i was in absolute fear everytime melo touched the ball. I judge players primarily by how they play in the playoffs and especially when they face the Lakers. Melo put more fear in me that year than anyone else. he was destorying our guys down low forcing doubles. he made kobe look like a little kid trying to guard him. we had no one. all we could do was pray he missed. he may have missed shots, but there was no denying he was the best player on that team and second best player on the floor.

if it wasn't for a superhuman effort by Kobe, i think he averaged 35/5/5 that series, we woulda lost.

I like 'Melo and agree with most of what you've said so far (haven't finished page 3) but 'Melo is not close to Kobe. I can't remember one shot that Kobe got that wasn't on 1 foot, fading away or more difficult, yet, he was still very efficient in that series. Kobe is a killer.

 

[duckbutta]

Could you put Chris Paul on Melo

How about Tony Allen

Melo ever had the refs in his pocket

 

[Victim of Racism]

I don't see any quotes, you said that you bet Bron would call Melo his toughest competition, meanwhile his biggest rivals are Paul Pierce and Durant, from his own mouth

You're arguing that Pierce is tougher competition for Lj than 'Melo? Well, Pierce did have his way against Lj because Lj doesn't guard but still.

 

[FlyRy]

Yeah, pretty obvious at this point

4 scoring titles
1 MVP
3 conference finals appearances
1 nba finals appearance
ROTY

And he's only 25

and i think he sat out one game that woulda gotten him a 5th scoring title

melo's never gonna win shyt

 

[GreatestLaker]

Could you put Chris Paul on Melo

How about Tony Allen

Melo ever had the refs in his pocket

Could you put Luke Walton on Kevin Durant?

Melo's stats in the 08 playoff vs the Lakers - 22.5 points on 37 FG% with Luke being his primary defender.

 

[Swagnificent]

and i think he sat out one game that woulda gotten him a 5th scoring title

melo's never gonna win shyt

well if we're gonna play that game, Durant got the 2012 scoring title cause Kobe sat out the final game.

 

[GreatestLaker]

You're arguing that Pierce is tougher competition for Lj than 'Melo? Well, Pierce did have his way against Lj because Lj doesn't guard but still.

Melo isn't touching prime Paul Pierce. Stop it.

 

[Swagnificent]

Could you put Luke Walton on Kevin Durant?

Melo's stats in the 08 playoff vs the Lakers - 22.5 points on 37 FG% with Luke being his primary defender.

at least Luke is 6'8". only thing worse than being shut down by a 5'11" point guard is being shut down by muggsy bogues.

 

[duckbutta]

Could you put Luke Walton on Kevin Durant?

Melo's stats in the 08 playoff vs the Lakers - 22.5 points on 37 FG% with Luke being his primary defender.

How man inches does melo have on luke walton? How many pounds does he have on Luke Walton?

If you stack to CP0's on top of each other, are they tall as Duref? Do they weight as much

 

[GreatestLaker]

at least Luke is 6'8". only thing worse than being shut down by a 5'11" point guard is being shut down by muggsy bogues.

Melo couldn't do shyt on Luke who was an awful defender. Couldn't drive past him, post him up, shoot over him, nothing. Luke had that nikka's number.

 

[Propaganda]

what year is this? 2010?

there is literally no argument for melo over kd. durant's a better player, has better stats, has more playoff success and has a better resume.

you might "like" melo better but that doesn't mean he is better. it seems like a lot of dudes don't understand the difference.