How good/bad was Nas' I Am...

How do you rate I Am...


  • Total voters
    151

Pop123

Peace
Joined
May 13, 2012
Messages
29,816
Reputation
6,776
Daps
112,713
Reppin
NULL
3.5 just cause it’s Esco and his rapping is always gonna keep his joints above trash.

4-5 absolute gems on there. Mostly ehh tho, production sucks. The original I Am how he wanted to release it was 🔥
 

Sean7

All Star
Joined
Oct 3, 2012
Messages
1,505
Reputation
545
Daps
3,105
Reppin
NULL
^^^^^^^^
3.5, if the bootleg dropped though it would be 4+ IMO... As said above 4-5 absolute GEMS on there and a few duds a well a few mediocre tracks. The original album was straight fire but too much got removed to hit classic status.
 

The Intergalactic Koala

Reporting for Duty
Supporter
Joined
Jan 2, 2017
Messages
64,666
Reputation
24,348
Daps
264,947
Reppin
Koalabama and the Cosmos
Great album except for a couple trash songs and alot of the sorry ass hooks… but it has some of nas best songs on there

The main problem with I Am, was the fact that it's dated as hell even for a Nas album. You had those "digital thug" ass beats, the corny stuttering flow, a few random tracks (Dr Knockboot), and quite frankly the whole album just felt like it was cut off from the original direction. Which we all later found out (mainly this marsupial) that the album was supposed to be a double disc.


I wonder if Nas was able to drop the original album around the time. Would it still be considered meh? Or it would have been a instant classic?
 

904

I pick shyt up
Joined
May 8, 2012
Messages
13,206
Reputation
1,955
Daps
33,362
Reppin
Vixens, Mascara's, Mary-Ann's
Starts absolutely classic.. Then the mid hits

I actually like Dr Knockboot though...

overall I'd say it's right under a 4... High highs and has some low lows.. I don't revisit this album as much as I thought I would...
 

Stick Up Kid

Veteran
WOAT
Joined
Aug 29, 2012
Messages
31,951
Reputation
-13,986
Daps
155,201
Reppin
Newark NJ
Any song with the caliber of

Nas is Like
Hate Me Now
Small World
Ghetto Prisoners
We Will Survive
NY State of Mind 2
Undying Love
Favor for a Favor

is a 4 to 4.5 Mic album.......

Nas is the only rapper where every song on it has to be great to be considered a classic album.
There's fillers on All Eyez on Me, Dre 2001, Wu Forver, Blueprint etc.
 
Top