1. Rodgers
2. Manning
3. Luck.
2. Manning
3. Luck.
How good is Andrew Luck?
- Thread starter FakeNews
- Start date
mastermind
Rest In Power Kobe
Matt ryan so underrated, look at them numbers
explain how ice melts in January doeStatistically top 5 in every category, that's my quarterback
all crakkkas i see. fukk outta here. RG3, Russ, Kaep, and Cam are all better than him.
Born2BKing
Veteran
So you're discounting Wilson because he has a good RB? Can't be because he is a good QB?I thought u were smarter than this. So disappointing
Please give Andrew Luck a top 5 rusher and lets see his stats.
Tony D'Amato
It's all about the inches
He's good, he's not Andrew Luck good. Andrew Luck faces nickle and dime coverages on a consistent basis. U are not using those defenses vs beast mode too often. He also has a horrible defense and despite what Sea fan will say, Luck had the worst oline. Hes constantly throwing with hands on him and people at his feet.
My top 10 qbs are
Rodgera
Manning
Brady
Brees
Ben
Romo
Luck
Kaep
Wilson
Rivers
BlakeSuperior
and The Scene
He has to make the jump THIS YEAR or he's officially overrated. They call him elite too often and he just hasn't been.
Lol. Luck has already hit his ceiling. Y'all gon learn this season
Tony D'Amato
It's all about the inches
ceiling? Yeah, ok.MustafaSTL
Achievement In Every Field of Human Endeavor
You're trolling, right?
He's good and has the skills to be someday be great. But the amount of dikk guzzling the NFL and ESPN is doing for this guy is atrocious 
To say he's a level above Kaep, Wilson, and Cam right now is ridiculous.They are all around the same ballpark. At this point I'd definitely put Russell ahead of him.
To say he's a level above Kaep, Wilson, and Cam right now is ridiculous.They are all around the same ballpark. At this point I'd definitely put Russell ahead of him.
Tony D'Amato
It's all about the inches
They are not the same. U look @ stats and assume they are. People who actually know football know there isnt a young qb asked to do what Andrew Luck is. More is asked of him, more is expected of him and last yr his offense was riddled with injuries and he still won. And he has the worse defense among all those qbs u named.He's good and has the skills to be someday be great. But the amount of dikk guzzling the NFL and ESPN is doing for this guy is atrocious
Wilson is underrated....I think he'll be an all timer and he'll get even more pub once Seattle's defense regresses.
But Luck is legit too- hit his ceiling? How do you figure that? The Colts did beat the Seahawks and Niners last year....Luck probably had the most success of any QB throwing against Seattle too.
But Luck is legit too- hit his ceiling? How do you figure that? The Colts did beat the Seahawks and Niners last year....Luck probably had the most success of any QB throwing against Seattle too.
Yall get too into rating QB's like there is really a way to tell what others would do in certain systems.
Luck, as a talent is one of the better QB's. Save me the advanced stats that make a case one way or the other. Watching the games, you can tell he has a control over what's going on out there. Of course the major media is gonna be all over this guy because they're invested in him being great. Don't let what they do sway you from the facts.
All of the young QB's in the game are really good. If everything is equal, Playmakers, O-Line, Defense...I think Luck or Kaep would be the two QB's who are the most talented and put the most fear into defenses. Luck's decision making has been kind of iffy at times but you can't discount the ability to make that big throw that can turn a game around. That KC game showed me that he is the leader of that team and they will go as far as he can take them. Hopefully they get the talent around him and it stays healthy so we can see
Luck, as a talent is one of the better QB's. Save me the advanced stats that make a case one way or the other. Watching the games, you can tell he has a control over what's going on out there. Of course the major media is gonna be all over this guy because they're invested in him being great. Don't let what they do sway you from the facts.
All of the young QB's in the game are really good. If everything is equal, Playmakers, O-Line, Defense...I think Luck or Kaep would be the two QB's who are the most talented and put the most fear into defenses. Luck's decision making has been kind of iffy at times but you can't discount the ability to make that big throw that can turn a game around. That KC game showed me that he is the leader of that team and they will go as far as he can take them. Hopefully they get the talent around him and it stays healthy so we can see
They are not the same. U look @ stats and assume they are. People who actually know football know there isnt a young qb asked to do what Andrew Luck is. More is asked of him, more is expected of him and last yr his offense was riddled with injuries and he still won. And he has the worse defense among all those qbs u named.
People always use that dumbass argument when they're trying to make a point."If you actually watch him play" "He does sooooo much more" Why? Because you said so? I watch him play quite a bit seeing as he's in the same division. Like I said the guy is good, but he's still very erratic with some throws and has a bad habit of throwing straight to DB's. In other words inconsistent with a high ceiling. I didn't need advanced statistics to tell me this, I watch him play. And as much as people want it to be, a QB's success is not directly correlated to how good their defense is, especially in the modern NFL. Kaep has the most offensive talent out of the QB's listed, but I'd argue that Luck has more to work with than Cam and Russ.
"He has to do sooooo much more, so we can forgive him when he throws a pick 6, when the ball should have never been thrown" Fukk outta here
I actually think Luck is a great guy, but the unnecessary hype and apologist when you disprove the hype is unbearable.
Don't even get me started on that CAC Jaworski