I was on the Panthers board and they all saying Bryce Young is a bust. I hate to say this but

vino

Superstar
Joined
Jun 21, 2014
Messages
6,231
Reputation
626
Daps
22,038
Qb’s only get one rookie season to prove themselves?
 

mozichrome

Veteran
Supporter
Joined
Oct 17, 2012
Messages
86,252
Reputation
3,565
Daps
124,114
Reppin
NULL
How about we give the brother time
Stroud coming out balling hasn't helped Bryce case but Adam Theilen is his best Wr
Folks can't name other weapons on carolina
 

Piff Perkins

Veteran
Joined
May 29, 2012
Messages
53,519
Reputation
20,011
Daps
292,951
They won't have the draft ammo to pull a Josh Rosen and take another QB high so they gotta roll with Bryce. He's looked bad but that team just sucks so I can't say he will be a career journeyman or anything like that. They dismantled the great run game they had last year, they don't have enough weapons at WR or TE either. Get him weapons and then see what happens.

Worse thing about that 1st round track is that there's gonna be some really good WRs in the first round who would help Bryce. Keon Coleman, Rome Odunze, and of course Marvin Harrison Jr. Brock Bowers is another dude who could be the big weapon he'd need. But none of those guys will be there in the second round.
 

FTBS

Superstar
Joined
May 29, 2012
Messages
20,381
Reputation
3,470
Daps
55,469
Reppin
NULL
So why are we not blaming coaching/personnel around him like people like to do with other QBs? Do you think he looks this bad if he goes to the 9ers or the Eagles? Hell, it's his rookie season so it should be expected that he struggles especially playing for a team like the Panthers.
I am not calling him a bust yet. However, how many busts do you see in good situations? Does it happen? Of course. But the overwhelming majority if them are in shytty situations and they still get called busts. As long as fans accept the QB savior model, this is the risk you will run as a highly touted QB.
 

Clark Wayne

Superstar
Joined
Jul 22, 2013
Messages
6,169
Reputation
967
Daps
20,145
Reppin
FL
Not looking good for him because of the optics between him and Stroud.

Not only that, it seemed like the Carolina staff wanted CJ but the owner stepped in and made the choice for Bryce.

This year is a wash but they don’t have a first round pick in 2024 and they have major issues to address with not just some offensive weapons but also the O-line.

Meanwhile the Texans have the Browns 1st round pick in 2024. The Browns are winning enough games so the Texans won’t be getting MHJ but Keon Coleman might be on the board.
 

Based Lord Zedd

Colts or Die
Supporter
Joined
Apr 30, 2012
Messages
11,308
Reputation
1,507
Daps
31,441
Reppin
Houston TX
Lol, did you see Peyton his first year?

Yes, because he's 6'5. Tougher with 5'10 Bryce.

He's smart but I think height/size will always be a limiting factor. If you put him in a situation where he's surrounded by talent or an elite HC/OC he could be effective.

But Panthers gave up weapons and picks to give him. In that spot you want someone who can carry a team and he hasn't shown flashes of that.
 
Joined
Feb 7, 2015
Messages
15,508
Reputation
2,171
Daps
58,274
Anyone making these kinds of statements have never taken a look at some of the best QB's to ever play.

Payton was still throwing a shyt ton of picks 4 years into his career :heh:

Drew Brees looked like ass his first 3 years :pachaha:

Tom Brady didn't really become THAT Tom Brady that can carry a team until he got Moss and after the injury (Mind you that's almost 8 YEARS INTO HIS CAREER)


Y'all gotta chill on the hot takes. Let these kids develop, shyt rarely just happens overnight.
 
Last edited:

MikelArteta

Moderator
Staff member
Supporter
Joined
Apr 30, 2012
Messages
258,657
Reputation
33,564
Daps
789,911
Reppin
Champions league
rookie qbs for the most part usually struggle their first year

Mahomes sat his first season, brees sucked, manning had like 28 ints, alex smith had 1 td and 7 picks his first year, andrew luck had 23 tds adn 18 ints, jared goff had 5 tds and 7 ints, trevor lawrence had 12 tds and 17 picks
 
Top