I was on the Panthers board and they all saying Bryce Young is a bust. I hate to say this but

[Apprentice]

He just looks incredibly small on the field. Even Kyler Murray looks bigger. I don’t know if he’s going to be a bust, I’ve only watched him against the Lions and he looked like a struggling rookie that game. What I think is safe to say, he’s not a win you 13 games a season off of pure ability and acumen on some Aaron Rodgers in the future, shyt. The Panthers fukked up.

How can u asses this in 8 games? Name the Panthers top 2 weapons

 

[Turk]

Ok then let’s just compare to this era

Lawrence was being called a bust after year one (turns out his coach was dogshyt)

Herbert was crowned as the next coming (this kid is constantly losing games he shouldn’t lose)

Tua was deemed a bust after two years (turns out his OC and coach were trash)

Jared Goff deemed a bust (might end up leading two different franchises to a SB appearance)

Carson wentz deemed the second coming (hasn’t even been a starting caliber qb since his injury)

Jalen hurts (I mean does anything really need to be said here considering what he is now????)

That’s 6 QBs from the most recent era and we can dig deeper into this. Making sweeping declarations about ANY nfl players in year 1 is fukking stupid

I'd also like to mention Josh Allen. His rookie year was bad and almost no one on this site had any faith in him.

 

[Godless Socialist CEO]

I'd also like to mention Josh Allen. His rookie year was bad and almost no one on this site had any faith in him.

Thought about going back to add Josh but considering the fact that he is a massive fukking outlier in QB development I kinda just left him out

 

[Born2BKing]

I'd also like to mention Josh Allen. His rookie year was bad and almost no one on this site had any faith in him.

Allen was picked #7 and seen as a project QB. Bryce was seen as a franchise changer hence going #1 and the trade for him.

 

[Apprentice]

Allen was picked #7 and seen as a project QB. Bryce was seen as a franchise changer hence going #1 and the trade for him.

His best wide receiver is a 30+ year old cac with no speed

This is an organizational failure

 

[Born2BKing]

 

[IIVI]

Yeah too early to write the book on dude.

Remember, you're talking about a kid who was considered the best HS QB in the nation then selected as the #1 pick. Then won the starting job.

The guy knows how to play QB.

Peyton Manning broke the touchdown record and not a single throw of his went 50 yards in the air because dude's arm was nearly cooked at that point.

The arm isn't going to hold Bryce back. Experience and having a decent team to work with will give us the definitive look.

It's pointless to make the call right now given how ass Carolina is.

Remember when everyone said Eli Manning was a bust?

 

[malbaker86]

Lol, did you see Peyton his first year?

Did you see JaMarcus his first year?

But yes, i’m not throwing in the towel on Young, too damn soon.

 

[Born2BKing]

His best wide receiver is a 30+ year old cac with no speed

This is an organizational failure

Houston has who? Besides Nico Collins, who wasn't seen as a top WR until Stroud showed up.

 

[Apprentice]

Houston has who? Besides Nico Collins, who wasn't seen as a top WR until Stroud showed up.

Tank Dell led the NCAA in receiving yards last year and every nikka knows he a real route runner

Nico Collins is easily better than Thielen rn

Bryce Young literally outplayed Stroud last week with a worst team

 

[Godless Socialist CEO]

ALSO HOW I FORGOT ONE QB.

HOW IN THE fukk ARE YALL STILL DOING THIS shyt AFTER EVERYTHING THAT HAPPENED TO GINO SMITH???????

 

[Born2BKing]

Tank Dell led the NCAA in receiving yards last year and every nikka knows he a real route runner

Nico Collins is easily better than Thielen rn

Bryce Young literally outplayed Stroud last week with a worst team

So Mingo's just chopped liver?

 

[Apprentice]

So Mingo's just chopped liver?

Watch the film I posted, Tank is miles better than him

Bryce’s #1 would be the worst for a starter rookie QB for some time

 

[Box Factory]

ALSO HOW I FORGOT ONE QB.

HOW IN THE fukk ARE YALL STILL DOING THIS shyt AFTER EVERYTHING THAT HAPPENED TO GINO SMITH???????

So is the hope that he'll have 1 good year in over a decade like Geno?

They're not even comparable as young prospects either. Completely different players

 

[Godless Socialist CEO]

So is the hope that he'll have 1 good year in over a decade like Geno?

They're not even comparable as young prospects either. Completely different players

Congratulations you completely missed the point.