Is Aaron Rodgers currently playing the best QB we've ever seen?

[FTBS]

Some of maintaining the lead can fall on the QB – like picking up a key third down with the lead and not turning it over. A lot of it involves other factors like the defense, coaching, and luck.

So far, while Rodgers’ close game record has not been great, it also involves a lot more than him. If his teams were holding leads like New England has for most of Brady’s career, we probably would not be reading about him today.

@FTBS

So are you agreeing with me or challenging me breh? I'm still tryna figure out who is trying to have it both ways...for Rodgers at least.

 

[Eternal Tecate]

wot. a. post.


the thing about that bolded part, the Packers had the most talented team in the NFL from 96-98. For some reason that is ignored.

That squad

fukk Elway

 

[Eternal Tecate]

5-4 in the Playoffs B, Talk to me when ya boy Reach the Conference Championship again. Lowkey he turning into Peyton Jr with them One and dones. And im not hating on the kid. He's GREAT, his accuracy and all that its on point but to put him in GOAT conversation is kind of reaching a lil bit.

Talk to me when Brady wins his first SB as the best player on his team

 

[Eternal Tecate]

It was the playoff game in Atlanta a few years ago that already had me saying he was the best eye-test quarterback I had seen

The surgical precision that he picked apart that team with was crazy. That was a great Atlanta team. He made them look like swiss cheese.

If you need a reminder

 

[Eternal Tecate]

Can't touch the QB
Can't hit WR's over the middle
Can't touch WR's
Less practice in pads


I put an asterisk beside all offensive stats in today's era.

What you do to counteract that is look at the stats in relation to the era's average

Look at this shyt dividing Career passer rating by the average passer rating during that player's career

That's from 2012. Godgers' current career average is 106.5 (). So his % now would be 106.5/81.1= 31.3% above average, moving him into 2nd place.

S/o Roger Staubach

 

[FTBS]

It was the playoff game in Atlanta a few years ago that already had me saying he was the best eye-test quarterback I had seen

The surgical precision that he picked apart that team with was crazy. That was a great Atlanta team. He made them look like swiss cheese.

If you need a reminder

That's the game that made me say " Okay we are dealing with something different here". He would have put on a similar display in the SB if it weren't for the drops. Dude would have broken all the SB records and blew the Steelers out if the WR could've held on to the ball.

 

[Carlos Huerta]

We gonna act like those 9ers weren't loaded with talent? We really gonna act like that? It's truly how the pendulum has swung all the way in the opposite direction with this dude. Dude was Peyton 20 years ago...with even better teams. He was the guy "always coming up short in the playoffs" who "couldn't get his team over the hump" now he's unassailable and the teams he was going against were too good. In 7 years as a starter he lost 3 home playoff games. By comparison Peyton "the choke artist" has lost 5 in 15 years. Does this mean that in 20 years people will be using the playoffs to hold Peyton over some future GOAT caliber QB?

his teams were great - not as great as the Cowboys. Peyton has lost a bunch of times to lesser teams.

I don't know anyone who puts Young over Manning by the way. Is that what you're saying?

 

[FTBS]

his teams were great - not as great as the Cowboys. Peyton has lost a bunch of times to lesser teams.

I don't know anyone who puts Young over Manning by the way. Is that what you're saying?

I do recall going back and forth with someone saying that, can't remember who. And you do have people in here saying he's GOAT or 2nd only to Montana. My main issue is people belaboring the playoff issues of other QBs with an equal number of rings as if Young didnt have his issues and doesn't just have 1 ring himself.

 

[Carlos Huerta]

I do recall going back and forth with someone saying that, can't remember who. And you do have people in here saying he's GOAT or 2nd only to Montana. My main issue is people belaboring the playoff issues of other QBs with an equal number of rings as if Young did have his issues and doesn't just have 1 ring himself.

Fair enough. I think Manning has had a better career, BUT if I had to choose between the two to win one game, it would be Young.

 

[mr. smoke weed]

QBR isn't the end all to be all, and Rodgers started starting in 2008

 

[Bboystyle]

Don't worry... they'll be done by New Years as usual

 

[TheNig]

Has that not happened the last two years?

 

[Bboystyle]

The A-Rod of football... Lots of Regular Season accolades, 1 Ring(2010), Less than Stellar in the Playoffs. Been in the playoffs 6 times, One and DONE 4 times, only reached the Conference Championship game ONCE(2010). He's good but he aint the GOAT b....

He's lost 32 Games and has had 7 Comebacks and 11 Game Winning Drives
Brady has lost 46 (14 more) games and has had 31 Comebacks and 41 Game winning Drives. Winning Brady is 157-46 and Rodgers is 67-32, Rodgers has to go 90-14 to catch the GOAT. Its not always about the gaudy numbers, its about situations and what you do to WIN THE GAME.

nikka u retarded as fukk


Playoff QB rating:

1. Bart Starr+ 104.8 1956-1971 gnb
2. Aaron Rodgers (31) 103.1 2005-2014 gnb
3. Kurt Warner 102.8 1998-2009 2TM
4. Drew Brees (35) 100.7 2001-2014 2TM
5. Joe Montana+ 95.6 1979-1994 2TM



LOL@ blaming Rodgers for losing in the playoffs. How is the 2nd most highest rated QB of all time in the playoffs the reason they lose?

again,u retarded as fukk

 

[Bboystyle]

Has that not happened the last two years?

Have u not been paying attention to the TEAM this year especially at home?

The fukk does last year or the year before have to do with this season?

 

[Bboystyle]

19-5 TD to int, when was the last time he had a Dominant game in the playoffs 2010? Tell me about all his memorable performances.... I'll wait.




18-8 In the Playoffs More wins than Manning & Rodgers, COMBINED.

Like I said before, Holla at me when ya Boy Reaches his SECOND NFC Championship. The only Playoff game he's won since 2010 Joe fukkING Webb was the starting QB.

WTF does playoff records have to do with individual talent?

Why your boy brady not even top 5 in passer rating in the playoffs?

Why u act like Brady aint have the best coach since Lombardi his whole career?

Why u act like Brady aint been shyt in the playoffs especially being 0-2 the last two SB appearances?

nikka u retarded as fukk