Is Destinys Child a top 5 Female R&B group of all time?

[BmoreGorilla]

Come on now breh. TLC was very innovative with their sound & style. You can credit the production team but you don't get that type of success with any other girl group with said production. League of their own.

The main problem is that the lead singer couldn't really sing

 

[Apollo Creed]

Would you use that same logic for MJ and the Jackson 5? Are they top 5 all time because of MJ in your eyes?

The Jacksons 5 ARE the GOAT BOY band. The Jacksons how ever arent even top 10 Male R&B groups since MJ left em by when they became the jacksons

 

[Apollo Creed]

Come on now breh. TLC was very innovative with their sound & style. You can credit the production team but you don't get that type of success with any other girl group with said production. League of their own.

Left eye sure. T Boz just sounded good on the production being that it was catered to her style, and the other girl was "just there".

 

[Archangel]

The main problem is that the lead singer couldn't really sing

I didn't say top 5 most talented though breh

 

[Remote]

Speak on it breh

Destiny's Child is a pop group with marginal singing ability at best.

They're "The Go-Gos" of the 2000s.
Just because they had hits doesn't make them great.

*NSYNC had hits. That doesn't make them the Earth Wind and Fire of the 90s.

 

[Archangel]

The Jacksons 5 ARE the GOAT BOY band. The Jacksons how ever arent even top 10 Male R&B groups since MJ left em by when they became the jacksons

I was playing devils advocate but I literally cannot think of 10 other male groups in front of J5.

 

[Here Comes the Pain]

View media item 12439Total over 702????

 

[Jordan>>LeFrozen]

Destiny's Child is a pop group with marginal singing ability at best.

They're "The Go-Gos" of the 2000s.
Just because they had hits doesn't make them great.

*NSYNC had hits. That doesn't make them the Earth Wind and Fire of the 90s.

 

[Apollo Creed]

I was playing devils advocate but I literally cannot think of 10 other male groups in front of J5.

You cant compare adult R&B groups to the J5. You gotta compare the Jacksons to those, and the Jacksons werent that great.

Imo you gotta compare J5 to like immature,b2k, new kids on the black, New edition pre Johnny gill, etc.

 

[Doobie Doo]

Lets be real, TLC is terrible if you remove the amazing production.

Oh best believe every WORST voices in R&B list keep giving T-Boz a pass to fukk with Keith Sweat. But TLC is probably the highest selling group on this whole list.

 

[Doobie Doo]

Would you use that same logic for MJ and the Jackson 5? Are they top 5 all time because of MJ in your eyes?

No Tito on the guitar and Jermaine singing backup is who the people came to see.

 

[Archangel]

You cant compare adult R&B groups to the J5. You gotta compare the Jacksons to those, and the Jacksons werent that great.

Imo you gotta compare J5 to like immature,b2k, new kids on the black, New edition pre Johnny gill, etc.

I understand your point. I think J5s catalog can stand up to adult R&B greats off the strength of "Whos Lovin You" alone. I don't really separate J5 and the Jacksons either. They're both the same to me even though the lineup changed.

 

[Apollo Creed]

I understand your point. I think J5s catalog can stand up to adult R&B greats off the strength of "Whos Lovin You" alone. I don't really separate J5 and the Jacksons either. They're both the same to me even though the lineup changed.

To me comparing J5 to Jodeci is like compareing Mike jordan to Bo Jackson.

Its not fair to either.

 

[Remote]

 

[Doobie Doo]

You cant compare adult R&B groups to the J5. You gotta compare the Jacksons to those, and the Jacksons werent that great.

Imo you gotta compare J5 to like immature,b2k, new kids on the black, New edition pre Johnny gill, etc.

So a group that changes members is not the same band no more? And you are in the Destiny's Child thread saying this?