Is Josh Allen the most overrated QB in the league?

[Biscayne]

Favre was throwing over 20 picks fairly regularly. This isn't even close.

Allen has a lower pick rate than Peyton for godsakes.

Peyton played in the pocket era. Where QBs had to throw more than they do now. Part of Allen’s whole schtick is supposed to be his escapability and gettin it done with his legs. And yet, he’s still a turnover machine. When he throws it, it’s alywas a risk.

 

[KidJSoul]

Allen has a bad supporting cast? He has a top 5 Wide receiver(Diggs), top 3 Tight End Duo(Knox a Pro bowler las year, Dalton Kincaid having one of the best TE rookie seasons in the history of the NFL) a decent running game and TWO pro bowlers(Dion Dawkins and Mitch Morse) on the offensive line. Not to mention a defense that keeps them in games. What else does he need? Derrick Henry?

The Bills currently have 12 players that have made the pro bowl.

Their receiving corps is weak outside of Diggs. Knox drops so many crucial catches, Gabe Davis stinks. They don't run the ball consistently well, and their online isn't consistent either.

Currently CJ a rookie, Jared fukkkng Goff, Bayker fukking Mayfield, Herbert, Dak, Noodle arm Tua, Hurst, Lamar to an extent, are all playing the position better than Allen this year.

Goff, Baker, Tua, really? And again, watch Hurts this year specifically. He's not been playing that great. He's bailing out of clean pockets. AJ Brown is bailing him out a lot when his first read isn't there, and he's rarely ever under pressure

 

[ZEupTWN]

Josh Allen has stagnated but so have the Bills as a team

I figured they wouldn't nothing special when I saw they didn't upgrade in the offseason especially offensively

 

[premier58]

Josh Allen has stagnated but so have the Bills as a team

I figured they wouldn't nothing special when I saw they didn't upgrade in the offseason especially offensively

So true. It always boggles my mind when teams who havent won a thing, are arrogant and complacent.

 

[Loose]

Stop!!! That Bills defense as firing on all cylinders. Cook had a running game for the ages. It was literally Josh’s INT before the half that gifted Denver 3pts, and his boggled hand off to cook, is what cost them this game. I’ve never seen a QB make so many blunders, and it’s never his fault.

He had a terrible game and still put his Team in position to win with terrible play calling. His coach fielding 12 guys on the field during a fg is why they lost. You list the run game, once again the run game the coach refused to use

 

[28 Gramz]

Herbert is better. Same level arm talent with less mistakes. Guys been playing with a broken finger and still looks better than Allen this year, switch their defenses and the Chargers are a 2 loss team.

 

[Loose]

Herbert is better. Same level arm talent with less mistakes. Guys been playing with a broken finger and still looks better than Allen this year, switch their defenses and the Chargers are a 2 loss team.

No he's not, Herbert can't even make certain sideline throws, Herbert is horrible. He has had some of the best talent on offense in the league and consistently struggles to produce.

 

[Mike_Pipeson]

Boooooy, people will fight tooth and nail to defend mediocre white QBs... "he wasn't the reason they lost" with 11 ints for the season with 1/3 of the games left in the season

 

[Max Power]

He's not a workout warrior or an off season grinder. That's what separates the very talented from the elite. Right now he seems content with getting by on his gifts and what he learned in his first few years.



He's got his Hollywood bytch, Madden cover and can walk into any country club he wants for golf. If he wants to take that next step he needs to dedicate himself to the game. IF. He could just he content with his life, 99.99999999999999999% of humanity would be.

 

[feelosofer]

Josh Allen has not played well this year but the Bills as an organization seem really shaky.

Stephon Diggs clearly wants out of Buffalo

The other receivers out side of Stephon suck

Their offense is too reliant on Josh Allen playing hero ball and they ran the ball less than with Brian Daboll calling the plays.

 

[Loose]

Josh Allen has not played well this year but the Bills as an organization seem really shaky.

Stephon Diggs clearly wants out of Buffalo

The other receivers out side of Stephon suck

Their offense is too reliant on Josh Allen playing hero ball and they ran the ball less than with Brian Daboll calling the plays.

Knox been injured gabe is legit ass lol, and the others aren't worth naming tbh. Only bright spot for them has been Kincaid, he looks to be really good. Run game could be better, but coaching staff doesn't believe/lead with it. So many times yesterday they refuse to use the run and went 3-0 without one touch. Just a badly coached and gm'd roster.

 

[Apprentice]

Favre was throwing over 20 picks fairly regularly. This isn't even close.

Allen has a lower pick rate than Peyton for godsakes.

This ain’t the same NFL

If there was a standard deviation for QBs throwing picks I’m sure Allen would be way ahead of the curve in this NFL

 

[Piff Perkins]

The way media coddles Allen, Herbert, and Trevor Lawrence is hilarious man. Each of them fukking up in different ways. All of them doing shyt that would convince an org to move on from a black QB.

 

[Loose]

The way media coddles Allen, Herbert, and Trevor Lawrence is hilarious man. Each of them fukking up in different ways. All of them doing shyt that would convince an org to move on from a black QB.

Nah I don't agree, they definitely go in on Allen, Herbert on the other hand gets passes.

 

[No1]

Peyton played in the pocket era. Where QBs had to throw more than they do now. Part of Allen’s whole schtick is supposed to be his escapability and gettin it done with his legs. And yet, he’s still a turnover machine. When he throws it, it’s alywas a risk.

Nah, QBs definitely throw more now. Peyton has a higher INT rate because guys like him and Brady started when you could still push WRs and be physical. There were less free releases.